PDA

View Full Version : Oil and Water: Key to Weight Loss?



CHUBAKAH
November-15th-2005, 05:24 PM
http://abcnews.go.com/GMA/print?id=1310260


Oil and Water: Key to Weight Loss?
The Shangri-La Diet Said To Suppress 'Caveman' Instincts
Nov. 14, 2005 — - A spoonful of sugar helps your weight go down, according to one University of California, Berkeley professor.

Seth Roberts says he lost 35 pounds in three months by drinking tablespoons of oil and glasses of sugar water in-between meals to quell the urge to continue to eat.

"I take one tablespoon a day of extra virgin olive oil," said Roberts, a psychology professor. "That's for me. For other people it could be different. And when I'm in a café, I have a cup of hot sugar water."

Roberts calls it the Shangri-La Diet, and suggests it works by suppressing a basic "caveman" instinct from days when access to food was intermittent. The diet tricks the body from thinking it needs to eat every last bit of food before an impending famine.

"It isn't really a fad diet," said Stephen Dubner, co-author of the "Freakonomics" column in The New York Times. "It's more about understanding the theory behind eating. It's not about denying things. It ultimately leads to lessening the amount you eat. In effect, by taking this canola oil and this sugar water, you're tricking your metabolism."

Dubner and his co-author, Steven Levitt, tried the diet themselves. Dubner said he lost 5 to 6 pounds over the course of a couple weeks, and had a "shockingly" easy time skipping lunch. Dubner said he wasn't really trying to diet, but Roberts, who began the diet at 200 pounds, eventually lost 40 pounds. His friend lost 80 pounds in six months on the Shangri-La Diet.

"This is an incredibly simple and elegant way of understanding what appetite is about," Dubner said. "The novelty of this is trying to persuade you to be more disciplined and tricking the system."

So what are your thoughts on this report?

SkinsHokieFan
November-15th-2005, 06:14 PM
Did they exercise at all?

Buddha
November-15th-2005, 06:33 PM
You don't need to "trick" your metabolism in order to lose weight. You just need to decide to permanently change the way you eat. I have lost about 35 pounds just by deciding to drastically cut my sugar and dairy intake, and to resist any urge to snack.

stevenaa
November-15th-2005, 07:30 PM
You don't need to "trick" your metabolism in order to lose weight. You just need to decide to permanently change the way you eat. I have lost about 35 pounds just by deciding to drastically cut my sugar and dairy intake, and to resist any urge to snack.


Yet some lose weight by eating smaller portions but snacking in between meals. I think the key is finding what works for you. We are made up of many cultures, (melting pot) and our metabolisms are vastly different. Different cultures react to food differently.

Thiebear
November-15th-2005, 07:34 PM
I love the diets that tell you to:
Eat better and Excercise.. heck if I did that I wouldnt need to diet. :)

The skinny girl I eat lunch with eats 1/4 of what I eat.. In the FBI they call that a clue.