NFL :Trade rumor Cowboys for Shaub!!

[SeanTaylor#21]

the NFL Rumors stated that the Cowboys were trading their 1st and 2nd Rounders for Matt Schuab. He said to expect it to be done Thursday or Friday
What do you think?:dallasuck:dallasuck:dallasuck:dallasuck:dal lasuck

[Westbrook36]

Shaub is great. Dammit. :(

[bubba9497]

Trades can't happen until March

[jrockster21]

No way that is true...1st and 2nd rounders for Matt Schaub?? I hate the bastard, but now way is Jerrah that stupid.

[skinfan2k]

matt schuab would be a great fit in dallas. he has good mobility and he is a very smart qb.. but i think giving up a 1st and 2nd round draft pick is a little too much to give up.. it will probably take him a year to learn the system..

[jrockster21]

Shaub is great. Dammit. :(


:confused:

He is barely a 50% passer. He has shown nothing to indicate he is worth a first AND second rounder. Maybe a 2nd...he wasn't even a first round pick!! (IIRC).

If it is true (hopefully), that means the price for Ramsey will go up dramatically, and we may even be able to get a first for him. :)

[wahoos911]

hahahahaha

this makes me laugh

[Cooked Crack]

Shuab is the second most important player for Atlanta. Don't like the sound of this trade one bit.

[Mr. Grundle]

That's alot to give up for a backup QB. He has looked good though when he has played. I'd rather they had Bledsoe in there, for sure.

[Walking Deadman]

That's alot to give up for a backup QB, even though Shaub has impressed me in the minimal times I've seen him play.

I don't buy it though, I didn't think Parcells was ready to call an end to the Bledsoe experience yet.
Plus, isn't Shaub too young? I thought you had to be in your mid/late 30's to qualify as a Dallas QB nowadays.......I'd buy Dallas trying to get Brunell for those picks than a youngster like Shaub.

Yes, Dallas fans, I was kidding.......

[REEGSKINS]

Trades can't happen until March
i think trades can happen they just cant be made final until march. didnt we trade for brunell and portis before the trading period.

[Westbrook36]

A 1st and 2nd might be too much but I don't want the Cowboys getting a franchise QB. I love them toiling with Bledsoe for a few years then handing it over to Henson. :laugh:

[fdarugar]

Only time will tell...Shaub has looked good backing up Vick but still has proved nothing in the league, do you think this will mean the departure of Bledsoe?

[Westbrook36]

I just went to both the Falcons and Cowboys board and no threads on this. You'd think if it was on the NFL network, fans from these teams would have seen it and have talked about it......

[bubba9497]

i think trades can happen they just cant be made final until march. didnt we trade for Brunell and portis before the trading period.

we wouldn't allow Brunell in Snyder's Superbowl party for fear of tampering.

maybe back door talks, but can't be made public, definitely not next Friday

[jrockster21]

I just went to both the Falcons and Cowboys board and no threads on this. You'd think if it was on the NFL network, fans from these teams would have seen it and have talked about it......


Which is more proof that the original poster is full of crap.

Lock the thread!!

[bubba9497]

I just went to both the Falcons and Cowboys board and no threads on this. You'd think if it was on the NFL network, fans from these teams would have seen it and have talked about it......


bogus rumor, is my bet

[SkinsHokieFan]

I would love to see the Boys waste a first and second on Schuab

You'll have a weaker armed Drew Bledsoe

[GSF]

Probably bogus, but I hope this rumor is true for 2 reasons. First, I don't think that Schaub is as good as a lot of people think. Second, if Dallas is willing to give up that much for Schaub, the value for Ramsey might be higher than many think.

[H-O-G]

Matt Schaub is good. CRAP.

[fdarugar]

Why do people start these bogus rumor threads??? I just dont ****in get it?

[SeanTaylor#21]

Here there is on another Cowboys Forum

(http://www.footballsfuture.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=41794)

[SeanTaylor#21]

Which is more proof that the original poster is full of crap.

Lock the thread!!
Chill MAN
Here another Cowboys Forum

(http://www.footballsfuture.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=41794)

[SeanTaylor#21]

Which is more proof that the original poster is full of crap.

Lock the thread!!
Chill MAN
Here another Cowboys Forum

(http://www.footballsfuture.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=41794)

[FootballGuy2677]

A 1st and 2nd might be too much but I don't want the Cowboys getting a franchise QB. I love them toiling with Bledsoe for a few years then handing it over to Henson. :laugh:


Yea lol, or Romo, the cowboy fans seem pretty high on him lol....i hope he starts this season.

[RiggoReincarnated]

the NFL Network stated that the Cowboys were trading their 1st and 2nd Rounders for Matt Schuab. He said to expect it to be done Thursday or Friday
What do you think?:dallasuck:dallasuck:dallasuck:dallasuck:dal lasuck

To me this sounds silly. The major issue for them seemed to be pass protection rather then at QB. If I was Jerry I'd address their offensive line and running game first.

[RiggoReincarnated]

Matt Schaub is good. CRAP.

Who says hes good?

[RiggoReincarnated]

Probably bogus, but I hope this rumor is true for 2 reasons. First, I don't think that Schaub is as good as a lot of people think. Second, if Dallas is willing to give up that much for Schaub, the value for Ramsey might be higher than many think.

Why would Schaub be worth any more then Ramsey?

[SkinsD]

Don't people have something better to do than think up bogus crap - I can't believe half the posters thought this was legit...

[GSF]

Why would Schaub be worth any more then Ramsey?

I don't think he would be, and I don't believe the pukes would give up that much for Shaub. My point was that if this rumor is even close to being true, then Ramsey would be worth more then most think.

[SkinzFan007]

the cowboys first and second is worth the equivalent of the 10th overall pick which many think that cutler might go. that being the case id rather have shcaub over cutler at this point anyday.

[andyburd]

That would be a UBGAY QB, if VMI can have women, why can't UVA have men?

[SkinsTillIDie]

With slightly more than their first and second rounder, they could move up and take one of the highly touted rookie qb's... Perhaps even Jay Cutler.

I believe Atlanta said a year ago that they wouldn't accept anything less than a first rounder... I'd be surprised if he's worth a 1st and a 2nd.

[FightForOldDC21]

that would be stupid

[portis&taylor]

whoppy matt shaub isnt better then bledsoe 1st and 2nd rounds u gotta be kidding me

[TheSource]

I would love to see the Boys waste a first and second on Schuab

You'll have a weaker armed Drew Bledsoe

Oh, there you go! The Hokie in you speaks out, without thinking. That type of comment is about as well thought out as a Michael Vick audible.

Not only is your idea incomplete, it was just picked off and taken back for a TD.

If Schaub were at QB in Atlanta, they would have made the playoffs. Instead they are starting one of the most stupid (but most athletic) QBs in the league.

:doh:

[SkinzFan007]

Schaub iss pretty damn good. i've like him since his days at uva. He's got prototype size and is a pure pocket passer with a great arm.

Plus, that would open up the doors for atl to draft marcus vick in the late rounds to back up his big bro...

[RiggoReincarnated]

Schaub iss pretty damn good. i've like him since his days at uva. He's got prototype size and is a pure pocket passer with a great arm.

Plus, that would open up the doors for atl to draft marcus vick in the late rounds to back up his big bro...

Is he any better then Ramsey though who also has prototype size and a great arm?

[TheSchwartz]

Gotta call BS on this. No way is Schaub worth 1st AND 2nd rounders. Heck he isn't even worth a 1st rounder. Wasn't he a 3rd round pick to begin with? If Atlanta got a 2nd for him it would be a major coup, and would prove that Ramsey is worth at least a 2nd as well...

And whoever said Schaub is mobile knows nothing of Schaub and his career at UVA. The guy's a pocket passer with as much mobility as Ramsey. He might be pocket aware, but to say he's mobile is just flat out wrong...

[moondog]

CRAP he's pretty damn good from what ive seen. But i dont feel that bad about it if they are giving up that much of him. i wish the guy a great career...if he doesnt go to dallas, if he does, eh to hell with him cuz thats where hes headed anyway

i am kinda worried though, he was ACC player of the year and has looked pretty good filling in for vick :rolleyes:

[Fifty Gut]

I'd love if Dallas did this, huge waste of drafts picks

so much hype for this UVA fool, feel free to waste all your first day picks (if true) on him Dallas :laugh:

[TC4]

So if true(And there is NO DAMN LINK so thus, till I see one, I ain't a-gonna buy it!!!!), then this is the end of the Drew Henson era in Big D

And a 1st AND a 2nd for him?

:rotflmao:

[RiggoReincarnated]

Gotta call BS on this. No way is Schaub worth 1st AND 2nd rounders. Heck he isn't even worth a 1st rounder. Wasn't he a 3rd round pick to begin with? If Atlanta got a 2nd for him it would be a major coup, and would prove that Ramsey is worth at least a 2nd as well...

And whoever said Schaub is mobile knows nothing of Schaub and his career at UVA. The guy's a pocket passer with as much mobility as Ramsey. He might be pocket aware, but to say he's mobile is just flat out wrong...

What I'm wondering is why he would be worth more in a trade then Ramsey, who was a 1st round pick

[TheSchwartz]

What I'm wondering is why he would be worth more in a trade then Ramsey, who was a 1st round pick

Me too. Which was kinda my point. Everyone around here seems to overvalue a guy like Schaub for whatever reason. But when it comes to Ramsey they undervalue him for whatever reason.

Schaub started one game this year and lost. Has a career completion % under 50. Played the majority of two Atlanta games last year and both were losses...So he's 0-2 as a starter and completed < 50% of his passes.

Meanwhile Ramsey completes 55% of his passes, including a 60%+ clip last year, and has PROVEN to be a capable NFL starter with the potential for so much more.

And the talk is getting a 3rd rounder for Ramsey is somehow gonna be difficult, but giving up a 1st and 2nd for Schaub and only a few people flinch? Sounds like something wrong with that...

[dockeryfan]

I think Schaub is pretty good, but nowhere near that expensive.
It might be because I've seen more of Ramsey than fans of other teams, but I think Ramsey has more experience and more potential to succeed.

[SkinzFan007]

does anyone remember another inexperienced but promising young qb that atl traded away to the packers like 15 years ago? i forget his name...

[jimster]

If I'm not mistaken, Musgrave was OC at Va when Schaub was there - I don't know if he'd have a say in this though.

[ImmortalDragon]

Has this rumor been confirmed yet?

[TheREALJBird]

Hmm he's a good QB, but that's a hefty price for someone with not much expierience. I'll laugh if it happens though

[Macd36]

hahahahaha

this makes me laugh
ditto :dallasuck

[skinsdude]

This is just a rumor however Matt Shaub to the Cowboys would be BAD news for us Skins fans. I can see maybe a first round pick but not a first and second round pick. Shaub is the best QB on Atlanta's roster and the Falcons are not going to let him go. They need him for the many injuries that Michael Vick gets. Matt Shaub would improve the Cowboys immediately.

[erivera]

I wouldn't even trade a first and second round pick for Michael Vick! What NFL Network show were you watching?!!!:laugh: