PDA

View Full Version : ABC News: Woman arrested after reporting a Rape



TMK9973
February-1st-2007, 06:10 PM
This is when some common sense should have been applied. The fact that they wouldn't give her the morning after pill is even worse.

http://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory?id=2835475

Woman Jailed After Reporting Rape

College Student Jailed for 2 Days After Reporting Rape; Police Found Old Warrant

By PHIL DAVIS

The Associated Press

TAMPA, Fla. - A woman who told police she had been raped was jailed for two days after officers found an old warrant accusing her of failing to pay restitution for a 2003 theft arrest.

While she was behind bars, according to the college student's attorney, a jail worker refused to give her a second dose of the morning-after contraceptive pill because of the worker's religious convictions.



The 21-year-old woman was released Monday only after attorney Vic Moore reported her plight to the local media.



"Shocked. Stunned. Outraged. I don't have words to describe it," Moore said. "She is not a victim of any one person. She is a victim of the system. There's just got to be some humanity involved when it's a victim of rape."



Moore said the woman was not allowed to take the second emergency contraceptive pill until Monday afternoon, a day late, after reporters called police and jail officials.



Tampa Police Chief Steve Hogue said the arrest led to a new policy Tuesday that tells officers not to arrest a crime victim who has suffered injury or mental trauma whenever "reasonably possible." The agency also apologized to the student.



"Obviously, any policy that allows a sexual battery victim to spend a night in jail is a flawed policy," police spokeswoman Laura McElroy said.



The woman is not being identified by The Associated Press because she reported being the victim of a sex crime.



Tampa attorney Jennifer D'Angelo, who represents the jail worker, said Tuesday that her client is prohibited from giving inmates any medication without specific orders. The worker insists she never discussed religion with the woman who reported being raped.



"She was mortified at what was being reported in the press," said D'Angelo, who declined to identify the worker. "She's frightened for her job and she's frightened about community backlash about these allegations."



The employee, who has worked for a jail health care contractor for about six months, was placed on administrative leave, D'Angelo said.



Moore said it was too soon to say if his client would sue. Her first priority was making sure detectives find her attacker.



"She is brave," Moore said. "We are going to work with police to catch this monster."



She was in Tampa on Saturday for Gasparilla, an annual pirate-themed parade that draws thousands of people. She said she was walking alone to her car when a man pulled her behind a building and raped her, McElroy said.



She reported the rape Saturday afternoon, and officers took her to a rape crisis center where she was given the first of two doses of the morning-after pill, McElroy said. The second dose is supposed to be taken within 24 hours.



Later, as she was riding in a patrol car trying to locate the crime scene in the dark, police found the warrant stemming from a 2003 juvenile arrest for grand theft and burglary. It said she owed $4,585.



"They stopped the investigation right there," and put her in handcuffs, Moore said.



Authorities arranged a special bond hearing Monday. "When the chief's office learned we had a rape victim in jail, we began working very aggressively to get her out," McElroy said.



Jennifer Dritt, executive director of the Florida Council Against Sexual Violence, wanted more explanation from the jail, saying the woman's arrest "makes people think law enforcement doesn't have a victim-centered approach."



Moore said his client believes she paid the fine for what he described as a childish mistake. He didn't have details of that arrest, but the woman has no criminal history as an adult, according to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.



The sheriff's office, which runs the jail, said in a statement Tuesday that it is investigating the complaint and declined to comment further.






Copyright 2007 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Copyright © 2007 ABC News Internet Ventures

dreamingwolf
February-1st-2007, 06:19 PM
"They stopped the investigation right there," and put her in handcuffs, Moore said.

-----------

thats really the only part of the story I have a problem with, they should have still followed up the rape case but arresting her was perfectly fine. I also think denying her the morning after pill(if that is standard issue to rape victims) was messed up too. She was an outlaw, and thus should have resolved her rape herself by going after the rapist herself if she didnt want the law to catch up with her. The police definately should have continued to investigate the rape though, once she came to them and after they arrested her.

TMK9973
February-1st-2007, 06:26 PM
I disagree. She wasn't a outlaw, she had a arrest warrent. It's not the same thing. Most arrest warrent for things like that (Still owed money) mean no one is looking for them. They are on file somewhere.
They get her address, get her contact info, and that's it.

Frankly - I am much more concerned with a Rapist on the streets then I am about someone who owes money from when they were a minor. I wouldn't want to discourage victims from comming forward.

Larry
February-1st-2007, 07:03 PM
Unfortunately, as I understand it, (based on my vast law enforcement experience), discretion really goes out the window when the magic word "warrant" comes out. It means that a judge has issued an court order, ordering the police to do whatever is necessary to bring that person in to court.

(Now, maybe they could have arrested her, and taken her straight to a magistrate, who could order bail or some such. I really don't know what options they had after arresting her.)

TMK9973
February-1st-2007, 07:17 PM
There is always discretion. You ever get pulled over and a cop lets you go with a warning? They saw you break the law, The stopped you, and yet....

dreamingwolf
February-1st-2007, 07:20 PM
Outlaw was not a good term, but thats the first time Ive ever heard anyone say an arrest warrant is for collecting their addresses and phone numbers and not for arresting them when they are found. You've said you disagree with me on that, and gave your reason so I wont discuss that anymore with you.

I agree, and I said that earlier, that they should have persued the rape case.

TMK9973
February-1st-2007, 07:28 PM
Not a argue - But I'll give you a little funny story with arrest warrent.

Not all are equal -
I think we all agree Dallas is a screwed up place. Well - even more so when it comes to tickets.

When you get a ticket, you don't go to court. You need to go to the constable's office in the district you got pulled over in. (Who the F**K has constables anymore). So I get one, and they tell me to go to the constables office to pay it or fight it BY Dec 1st (This was sept).

So in Oct - I go. I was told that the police office "Had yet to turn in the ticket. It happens". So she took my name and number and told me she would record that I came.

Come January -I get a letter saying there was a arrest warrent for me for failing to pay the ticket.
3 days latter - At 8pm, I get pulled over. Freakin out, cause there is a arrest warrent for me.
Cop takes my license, comes back and says "Do you know there is a arrest warrent for you?". I say yes - Now what? Can I call my wife first to come get me?
He says "Oh no - The arrest warrent is a 8am to 5pm warrent. You just want to take care of it"

The arrest warrent was only vaild Mon - friday from 8am to 5pm (not counting holiday's) and only if I was found in that district. If I was, they would have to take me to the constable. Other then that, they were to get any updated contact info.

That was what my basis comes from....

Larry
February-1st-2007, 08:16 PM
The arrest warrent was only vaild Mon - friday from 8am to 5pm (not counting holiday's) and only if I was found in that district. If I was, they would have to take me to the constable. Other then that, they were to get any updated contact info.

Sounds to me like a jurisdiction that realizes that it doesn't make sense to spend hundreds of dollars and a valuable jail cell locking somebody up over a traffic ticket.

Also sounds like a rare jurisdiction. Sounds to me like Dallas is doing something smart.

dreamingwolf
February-1st-2007, 08:25 PM
Sounds to me like a jurisdiction that realizes that it doesn't make sense to spend hundreds of dollars and a valuable jail cell locking somebody up over a traffic ticket.

Also sounds like a rare jurisdiction. Sounds to me like Dallas is doing something smart.

Im thinking it wasnt a warrant, and if the office that collected the fines was open they would have brought him there to pay. If the story is even true, or is being described accurrately. I have never heard of an arrest warrant that could only be executed durring certain hours of the day.

TMK9973
February-1st-2007, 08:42 PM
Im thinking it wasnt a warrant, and if the office that collected the fines was open they would have brought him there to pay. If the story is even true, or is being described accurrately. I have never heard of an arrest warrant that could only be executed durring certain hours of the day.

I assure you it was true, happen in Plano Texas right off the George bush tollway. it's Accurate 'cause it happened to me! Tried to do a search for you on google on Texas arrest warrents found the Waco page where it shows over 1300 pages of people with traffic arrest warrent with the threat of jail, but mostly the fact that you can't renew your license.

http://www.waco-texas.com/leadership/municipal_court/warrants.htm

And yes -if the office was open they would have brought me in. But my point was that not all arrest warrents mean the cops are suppose to spend time and money tracking people down and dragging them to Jail.

Here's other ones -
This office in CO encourges you to turn yourself in if you have a warrent..... But only during busness hours...

http://www.weldsheriff.com/search.cfm


Persons wanting to turn themselves into the Weld County Combined Courts located at 901 9th Av, Greeley, (click here for a map (http://www.weldsheriff.com/ebail/map1.html)) may do so between 8am - 5pm at Rm 103 ground floor south end of the courthouse. You may obtain information from the courthouse by calling 970.351.7300 ext 4563. Anyone with an active warrant may turn themselves into the Weld County Jail at 2110 "O" St, Greeley. (click here for a map (http://www.weldsheriff.com/ebail/map2.html))


Or the one in Austin where in 2003 they opened on a Saturday just for the purpose of doing a warrent roundup, where they actually did go arrest people pro-activly... sorrta of.

The really only focused on the ones that had a lot of warrents..

http://www.ci.austin.tx.us/news/2003/roundup_03.htm


Law enforcement agencies from Austin, Bastrop, Burnet, Bee Cave, Cedar Park, Comal County Sheriff's Office, Georgetown, Killeen, Kyle, Lago Vista, Leander, Manor, Marble Falls, New Braunfels, Pflugerville, Round Rock and San Antonio, along with the Travis County Constables' Offices Precincts 1 through 4 and the Williamson County Constable's Office Precinct 4, announced today Feb. 14, that they will combine forces for an arrest warrant roundup. Officials will begin arresting persons with outstanding arrest warrants beginning on Saturday, March 1. Arrests will focus on residents with warrants in all of the participating jurisdictions.



Ok -I'm beating a dead horse. My point is that just because someone has a arrest warrent and the cops know where that person is, doesn't mean they need to excute it every time. In this case (Rape victim), they could have followed up on a later date.