Fantasy Help (Campbell related)

[OldTownFan]

I have two questions, one for each League (question #2 is below my roster for league #1)

1)
Question for my league, this is my team below, and I want to pick up Jason Campbell who is on waivers, cause Im feeling he will have a good season. Problem is, I already have Cooley and Portis as Skins on my team, and I don't want to go too Skiny Crazy. I was thinking maybe dropping Porter or Kitna, but Kitna has two good WRs in Williams and CJ to bomb TDs to, and Porter is the #1 WR in Oakland. I was thinking also maybe dropping manning.

Who should I drop to pick up Campbell, or should I leave my team alone for now?

QB Jon Kitna
WR Larry Fitzgerald
WR Deion Branch
WR Laveranues Coles
RB Frank Gore
RB Clinton Portis
TE Antonio Gates
BN Cedric Benson
BN Chris Cooley
BN Santonio Holmes
BN Eli Manning
BN Jerry Porter
BN Brandon Jackson
K Jeff Wilkins
DEF Philadelphia

Question #2
I have both JC and Vince Young in my other league, without bias and with all honesty, is it a no brainer to start Vince Young?

[twenty-eight]

I'd cut Holmes or Porter. Try and trade a RB for QB:2cents:

Now let me ask you something....Brandon Jackson is a RB for the packers, correct?


Yes you have to start Young.

[stoshuaj]

1. unless you get points for return yardage, I'd cut Holmes to pick up Campbell. While I think Eli sucks, he does at least still have some name appeal. Maybe enough to get you another 2nd or 3rd tier WR (better than SH anyway) from another owner who is jonesing for a QB

2. Two evenly matched qbs = play the matchups every week. If VY is playing the best D in the league and JC is playing the worst D in the league, why would you start VY?

[LongLostSkin]

Don't cut Holmes!! He really came on in the last quarter of the season and since the Steelers are going to have a more open passing game this year he should get more opportunities. He's got very good speed, hands, and open field running ability. He was the first WR picked last year, cmon.

Cut Jerry Porter if you must, he's done absolutely nothing in years....
Or cut Eli, he already sucks and now has lost Tiki..... I don't buy him 'suddenly having leadership skills' and throwing passes that are less than 8 feet about the WR's head. You don't want to root for a Giant anyways...


but personally I would leave the team as is, and only make one of these moves after Jason shows something.

[twenty-eight]

He cant cut Eli. You must improve at the QB position