On O: Which player can we least do without

[Veretax]

Of all our offensive players, which do you think would be the most difficult to do with out.

[Mass_SkinsFan]

Personally, I don't think there is ANYONE on this offense from players to coaches who is indispensible. We have O-Linemen who are made of paper mache. We have nothing of value at QB. Our RB's can't get the job done. Our WR's cannot catch the ball. Our O-Coordinator is an absolute joke. There's NOBODY in that group who I would say should be let off the hook.

[Veretax]

Tough Call there, Obviously Campbell, but I think if Rabach or Samuels was hurt then that would make things even more difficult, (See how campbell looked after we lost Rabach) And I'd add Cooley to that list :/

[skinsfan51]

Which player could the best three teams in the league (Pats, Colts, Cowboys) least afford to lose? Answer that and you have the corrrect answer.

[Veretax]

Which player could the best three teams in the league (Pats, Colts, Cowboys) least afford to lose? Answer that and you have the corrrect answer.

With the Pats its brady. With the Colts its Peyton, with the Boys though I think its Marion Barber. Without him their offense won't run as well, and when that happens the pass will get ganged up on.

[D'KanSkinFan]

Personally, I don't think there is ANYONE on this offense from players to coaches who is indispensible. We have O-Linemen who are made of paper mache. We have nothing of value at QB. Our RB's can't get the job done. Our WR's cannot catch the ball. Our O-Coordinator is an absolute joke. There's NOBODY in that group who I would say should be let off the hook.

For sake of arguement - I disagree with you, somewhat. What we have are IR'd players that are playing (contract agreement or not -let them heal - they're costing us games); we have backups coming in for regular players that HAVE not (or at least it looks that way) been practiced at a particular position- thus exposing our leader. We have an Offensive Coordinator that calls 1/2 to 3/4 of the plays (we hired him to call the plays - let him call all the plays on offense).

We have the talent, we just need someone STRONG enough to stay on top of them and bring them together as a team and NOT media hungry nerds............and most of all, our team needs to eat, sleep, breathe football until the season is over and not "9 hours a day"-:2cents:, Its been stated Campbell is there 20 hours a day studying football - where is everyone else while he is studying- his studying is showing through during the game. No excuses for not committing to success, my employer expects X amount of hours - if I can't fulfill that "contract" - he has options. Sick is one thing/ dedication, passion and committment for success to me and my team is another.

We need more players like Jason and obviously I am not talking abour our "D" line. :2cents:

[Lombardi's_kid_brother]

Right now, we need to store Chris Samuels in a box filled with styrofoam peanuts during the week.

[Bat~man]

Personally, I don't think there is ANYONE on this offense from players to coaches who is indispensible. We have O-Linemen who are made of paper mache. We have nothing of value at QB. Our RB's can't get the job done. Our WR's cannot catch the ball. Our O-Coordinator is an absolute joke. There's NOBODY in that group who I would say should be let off the hook.


LOL @ your sig and this post , you somehow think the team will see this and say "oh gosh people are mad , we better start winning" nothing of value at QB ? RBs that cant get it done? after 5 games , Portis is gimpy , I agree there , Betts isn't getting touches and has not been great , but look at our freakin O-Line injuries ~ .. Moss can't catch this year thats obvious , but ARE is doing good , Cooley doing ok , other WRs arent dropping like Moss , which we all know Moss will break out of it ... our O-coord isn't that bad players need to execute , duh , although is trick plays got to STOP , just STOP , but you , just go away

[Veretax]

Right now, we need to store Chris Samuels in a box filled with styrofoam peanuts during the week.

Are you suggesting that if they made a Chris Samuels figurine it would be a collectible? Ala ceramic or beanie baby or something? Man that is hilarious LOL

[OVCChairman]

I voted for Chris Cooley but i also believe Campbell is the cornerstone of the offense. I can honestly say that if it werent for Cooley, Campbell would have NO chance to throw. Cooley is a TE that opens up the run game, who can catch, but he can also block, and he does.

[Bacon]

I voted Campbell, Cooley, and Samuels. If they were to ever get hurt...:shot:

[Aston]

No brainer - Campbell. Poll would've been interesting if you said "Beside Campbell ...."

Really interesting.

[Cooley4President]

Campbell followed by Cooley. No question.

[RedskinsNation]

J.Campbell and there really isnt a close 2nd in my opinion.

I have to admit...i wasnt totally a JC believer but from what i have seen this year I really think he is going to be a very good quarterback in the league...he is well on his way already.

[Slacky McSlackAss]

Cooley does it all, without him, JC would struggle.

[KevinthePRF]

Our offense would be somewhere in the vicinity of dead last with Campbell out. He's made some mistakes but has consistently been our best player on offense through five games.

[Fifty Gut]

Campbell, Samuels, and Rabach are all equally as important to this offense

[CliffBattles]

Campbell followed by Samuels....our line is killing us, biggest reason after dropped passes that we lost yesterday's game.

Cooley is huge, but with the way our line is going, he could be replaced by a blocking TE....because, he won't have many more options than to do just that.

[bedlamVR]

I think right now with all the O Line injuries Samuels who has been playing on top of his game is the one guy we could ill aford to loose .

It all starts in the tranches and if the O line isn't clicking you could have Payton back there it wouldn't matter...

Hey Mass..missed you last week...at least the skins lost so you can come back from out of your rock

[Fifty Gut]

I hate that people underrate Rabach so much. He is key to everything our offensive line does, from mauling cats in the run game, to taking on huge nose tackles 1-on-1, to making all the calls in protection.

[mi6]

Campbell followed by Chris Cooley.

Our O-Line is aging, and is a joke. On the O-Line I would say Casey, and Stephon Heyer ... the rest can go into early retirement...

On WRs ... I like Moss and ARE ... but, if they have games like yesterday ... they can be replaced as well.

[pjfootballer]

Everything on offense begins and ends at the QB position. So it's JC.

[COOLeyCatchTds]

Personally, I don't think there is ANYONE on this offense from players to coaches who is indispensible. We have O-Linemen who are made of paper mache. We have nothing of value at QB. Our RB's can't get the job done. Our WR's cannot catch the ball. Our O-Coordinator is an absolute joke. There's NOBODY in that group who I would say should be let off the hook.


Easy bro. I wouldnt say Saunders is a joke. If Gibbs lets him do his job, Saunders does a fine job. And Cooley is a stud. But with our O-line as banged up as it is right now, the one guy we absolutely couldnt do without right now is Chris Samuels. Campbell would be worthless without an O-line. If Samuels went down, we would have zero starters on the line from just one year ago.

[ST+LL=Area51]

Without Campbell, this team would be 1-4 in my opinion. JC has done so much so early. I feel like a gitty school girl when thinking about the future with this guy slinging the ball around. After watching the game yesterday, and seeing what he can still do with NO protection and no running game, I was impressed.