2009 HOF-who gets in?

[DWinzit]

Who of this years finalists do you feel gets in next year?

Redskins guard Russ Grimm
Vikings receiver Chris Carter
Buffalo Bills receiver Andre Reed
Raiders punter Ray Guy
Broncos linebacker Randy Gradishar
Chicago Bears defensive end Richard Dent
Miami Dolphins guard Bob Kuechenberg
Vikings guard Randall McDaniel
Chiefs linebacker Derrick Thomas
Past NFL commish Paul Tagliabue
Cardinals RB Marshall Goldberg

[DWinzit]

My guess is Chris Carter, Randall McDaniel and Tag's are at the top of the list.

I think Bruce Smith and Clay Matthews are the first year eligibles.

[scotlandtech]

Cris Carter
Rod Woodson
Paul Tagliabue
Derrick Thomas
Bruce Smith

Randall McDaniel?
Sterling Sharpe?

[SteveFromYellowstone]

Roid Woodson, Sterling Sharpe and Bruce Smith deserve to make it. So do Cris Carter, Tagliabue, Ray Guy, Russ Grimm and Andre Reed.

[ECU-ALUM]

Carter, Smith, Sharpe, Woodson & Kuechenburg are my picks.

[Goaldeje]

My guess is Chris Carter, Randall McDaniel and Tag's are at the top of the list.

I think Bruce Smith and Clay Matthews are the first year eligibles.


I don't think Tags makes it. He didn't survive the first cut down this year, did he? From what I've read, he was somewhat similar to Monk in that he wasn't warm and cuddly with the media, so that will work against him.

It's a shame, really.

I would agree with the rest of your list, however.

[DWinzit]

Cris Carter
Rod Woodson
Paul Tagliabue
Derrick Thomas
Bruce Smith

Randall McDaniel?
Sterling Sharpe?I forgot about Woodson becoming eligible but I had an extra slot on my card;) . I think he is in also.

[DWinzit]

I don't think Tags makes it. He didn't survive the first cut down this year, did he? From what I've read, he was somewhat similar to Monk in that he wasn't warm and cuddly with the media, so that will work against him.

It's a shame, really.

I would agree with the rest of your list, however.You are correct Tag's didn't make the first cut down this year. I have a feeling he is in next year though and he does deserve it.

BTW, I just heard on the radio people complaning about Derrick Thomas getting gypped. I don't see it when comparing him to the others.

[Walking Deadman]

Joe Jacoby or Russ Grimm.

Now that we finally got Art in, it's now time to get at least 1 member of the Hogs in the HOF

[RammsteinSkins]

Who of this years finalists do you feel gets in next year?

Redskins guard Russ Grimm
Vikings receiver Chris Carter
Buffalo Bills receiver Andre Reed
Raiders punter Ray Guy
Broncos linebacker Randy Gradishar
Chicago Bears defensive end Richard Dent
Miami Dolphins guard Bob Kuechenberg
Vikings guard Randall McDaniel
Chiefs linebacker Derrick Thomas
Past NFL commish Paul Tagliabue
Cardinals RB Marshall GoldbergGrimm,Carter,Derrick Thomas,Shannon Sharpe,McDaniel get in but grimm would be the last to get in

[spjunkies]

I hope Tags makes it, you see the difference between him and this goofball Goodell already.

[BAFGA]

Cris Carter will get in....he shouldn't be disappointed he didn't get in this time around. He'll get in next year.

I think Bruce Smith is a first ballot guy...

Other than that? I have no idea.

I'm surprised that Andre Tippett got in. I thought he was a good LB when he played. Not great.

[DWinzit]

I'm surprised that Andre Tippett got in. I thought he was a good LB when he played. Not great.I agree he was a solid player but didn't seem to be on par with the others who were elected or a number of the guys that didn't make the final cut.