Post Draft Poll

[Walking Deadman]

Now that the draft is over, I have a follow up poll post-draft.

Here was the Pre-Draft Poll:
http://extremeskins.com/forums/showthread.php?t=245289

Questions:
#1. In your opinion what is/was the Skins biggest need pre-draft- choose only one:
(A) WR
(B) OL
(C) DL
(D) DB (CB or S)
(E) other position

#2. In your opinion do you Feel the Redskins addressed the biggest need during the draft?

(A) Yes
(B) No
(C) Undecided, they may not be able to b/c of who's left on the board (BPA)
or some other reason

#3. Based on the limited FAs available and the final selections during the draft do you think the Skins should have gone after more FAs?
(A) Yes
(B) No

#4. Did you feel the Skins put the draft picks to good use?
(A) Yes
(B) No
(C) Undecided

#5 Do you feel the FO did a good job in their evaluation of talent for this draft?
(A) Yes
(B) No

#6 When we made the pick for Devin Thomas what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#6a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#7 When we made the pick for Fred Davis what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#7a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#8 When we made the pick for Malcolm Kelly what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#8a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#9 When we made the pick for Chad Rhinehart what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#9a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#10 When we made the pick for JT Tyron what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#10a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#11 When we made the pick for Durant Brooks what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#11a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#12 When we made the pick for Kareem Moore what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#12a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#13 When we made the pick for Colt Brennan what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#13a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#14 When we made the pick for Rob Jackson what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#14a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#15 When we made the pick for Chris Horton what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#15a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#16 Were you happy with the outcome of this years draft?
(A) Yes
(B) No
(C) Undecided

#17 Were you happy with the FO moves during the draft and how we used the picks?
(A) Yes, Completely Happy
(B) No, Unhappy
(C) mixed opinion on the picks and trades (feel free to comment here)


#18 How many players that we drafted will be starters in the future in your opinion?
(A) 0-3
(B) 4-6
(C) 7-10

#19 How many players that we drafted this year will make significant contributions (either as regular back ups, temp. starters or STers) to the 2008 team?
(A) 0-3
(B) 4-6
(C) 7-10

#20 How many players that we drafted this year will make the active roster?
(A) 0-3
(B) 4-6
(C) 7-10
EXTRA: How many in your opinion will be on the practice squad?

#21 What do you expect to get out of the draft (you can pick more than one)
(A) Mostly Starters in 2008
(B) Depth/STers
(C) Future Starters in 2009 and beyond
(D) Busts

#22 Do you feel that the Skins will be able to address needs via UDFA post-draft?
(A) Yes
(B) No
(C) Undecided

[styx491]

#1. In your opinion what is/was the Skins biggest need pre-draft- choose only one:

(C) DL


#2. In your opinion do you Feel the Redskins addressed the biggest need during the draft?

(C) Undecided, they may not be able to b/c of who's left on the board (BPA)


#3. Based on the limited FAs available and the final selections during the draft do you think the Skins should have gone after more FAs?

(B) No

#4. Did you feel the Skins put the draft picks to good use?
(A) Yes


#5 Do you feel the FO did a good job in their evaluation of talent for this draft?
(A) Yes


#6 When we made the pick for Devin Thomas what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy


#6a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy


#7 When we made the pick for Fred Davis what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy, but it was more of a HUH?? thats so cool he's a beast, but what?? no DL??


#7a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy

#8 When we made the pick for Malcolm Kelly what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy, but same reaction as Davis (huh??? no dl??)


#8a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy


#9 When we made the pick for Chad Rhinehart what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy


#9a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy


#10 When we made the pick for JT Tyron what was your inital reaction?

(C) Undecided

#10a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy


#11 When we made the pick for Durant Brooks what was your inital reaction?

(C) Undecided

#11a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy

#12 When we made the pick for Kareem Moore what was your inital reaction?

(C) Undecided

#12a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick

(C) Undecided

#13 When we made the pick for Colt Brennan what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy, i think he'll do well with Zorn.


#13a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy


#14 When we made the pick for Rob Jackson what was your inital reaction?

(C) Undecided

#14a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick

(C) Undecided

#15 When we made the pick for Chris Horton what was your inital reaction?

(C) Undecided

#15a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick

(C) Undecided

#16 Were you happy with the outcome of this years draft?
(A) Yes


#17 Were you happy with the FO moves during the draft and how we used the picks?
(A) Yes, Completely Happy, but sometimes it was like, did we trade AGAIN? I wanna know some picks!! Can we get some players up in hizzle?!


#18 How many players that we drafted will be starters in the future in your opinion?

(B) 4-6

#19 How many players that we drafted this year will make significant contributions (either as regular back ups, temp. starters or STers) to the 2008 team?

(C) 7-10

#20 How many players that we drafted this year will make the active roster?

(B) 4-6

EXTRA: How many in your opinion will be on the practice squad? all the picks were good enough for practice squad.

#21 What do you expect to get out of the draft (you can pick more than one)
(A) Mostly Starters in 2008 (i think our first 3 round picks will start next year)
(B) Depth/STers
(C) Future Starters in 2009 and beyond (for sure they'll stay)
(D) Busts (only potential busts in my eyes are Devin and Colt)

#22 Do you feel that the Skins will be able to address needs via UDFA post-draft?
(A) Yes

[SkinsTerps26]

too many questions. its the weekend, i don't want to do extra hw.

[terpfan]

too many questions. its the weekend, i don't want to do extra hw.
LOL, yeah that's a lot of work.

My thoughts:
1 - D. Thomas: Would have liked Merling, but when he got picked, Thomas was my next choice. Liked the pick.

2 - F. Davis: Didn't like the pick at the time. Honestly, I didnt think we were in the market for a TE so I didnt do much research on him. After looking around a bit, I do like him and don't mind the pick. Having a second TE who is some kind of threat downfield (sorry Yoder) does sound intriguing.

3 - M. Kelly: Very interesting pick. I just kind of laughed at the time. I'm still not sure what to think. I would have liked more diversity with our first three picks, but I do love the value here. Taking a wait and see approach.

4 - C. Reinhart: I like that we took a guard. Seems like a good, versatile prospect and I trust Buges. No problems here.

5 - J. Tryon: A corner was another big need. He's undersized, but I like smaller just fine corners if they can make plays. If he can come in and be a nickel or dime back I will be happy.

6 - K. Moore: We definitely needed a safety. I would have liked a defensive lineman by this point, but with only 3 safeties on the roster it's hard to argue with this pick.

7 - D. Brooks: At the time of the pick, I was pissed. But after doing some research he seems like the real deal. I like this pick.

8 - C. Brennen: Interesting, to say the least. We definitely needed a developmental QB. Wish we had landed Josh Johnson or Erik Ainge. I'm far from sold on Brennen, but I have nothing against him. I still remember his ST tribute. We'll see if Zorn can work his magic.

9 - R. Jackson: Hey... at least we got a pass rusher... AMIRITE??

10 - C. Horton: Uhhhh.......

Overall, I think it's clear the coaches and scouts got players that they liked. The lack of quality linemen is disappointing (well, on defense at least, if the OG we got actually pans out I think we will be OK there) but I think we got good value. The pass-catcher-overload strategy is still up for debate. Who knows what we will think of Moss, ARE, Thomas, and Kelly a year or two from now. I'm willing to let it play out.

[Fieldy]

I answer all your poll questions with this thought...

I don't follow college football, so I don't know who most of these players are. The only thing I knew prior to the draft was where the Skins had needs and based on what needs we had, we addressed some(WR), and skipped others (DL). As disappointed as I am that we didn't address ALL needs, I have to put my faith in Snyderatto and hope that they know what is best for the franchise...as much as it pains me to do so.

[DarrellsMyHero28]

Questions:
#1. In your opinion what is/was the Skins biggest need pre-draft- choose only one:
(A) WR
(B) OL
(C) DL
(D) DB (CB or S)
(E) other position

#2. In your opinion do you Feel the Redskins addressed the biggest need during the draft?

(A) Yes
(B) No
(C) Undecided, they may not be able to b/c of who's left on the board (BPA)
or some other reason

#3. Based on the limited FAs available and the final selections during the draft do you think the Skins should have gone after more FAs?
(A) Yes
(B) No

#4. Did you feel the Skins put the draft picks to good use?
(A) Yes
(B) No
(C) Undecided

#5 Do you feel the FO did a good job in their evaluation of talent for this draft?
(A) Yes
(B) No

#6 When we made the pick for Devin Thomas what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#6a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#7 When we made the pick for Fred Davis what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#7a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#8 When we made the pick for Malcolm Kelly what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#8a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#9 When we made the pick for Chad Rhinehart what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#9a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#10 When we made the pick for JT Tyron what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#10a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#11 When we made the pick for Durant Brooks what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#11a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#12 When we made the pick for Kareem Moore what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#12a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#13 When we made the pick for Colt Brennan what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#13a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#14 When we made the pick for Rob Jackson what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#14a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#15 When we made the pick for Chris Horton what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#15a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy
(B) Unhappy
(C) Undecided

#16 Were you happy with the outcome of this years draft?
(A) Yes
(B) No
(C) Undecided

#17 Were you happy with the FO moves during the draft and how we used the picks?
(A) Yes, Completely Happy
(B) No, Unhappy
(C) mixed opinion on the picks and trades (feel free to comment here)

Trading down was a good move and Devon Thomas is a great pick. Having him and Kelly will bolster our WR corps. Fred Davis is a confusing pick but he's damn good and will help us in sets where we need two TEs. Picking a punter (even if he's good) and a career third stringer/backup QB in Brennen and ignoring the D-line until the 7th round is really frustrating.

#18 How many players that we drafted will be starters in the future in your opinion?
(A) 0-3
(B) 4-6
(C) 7-10

#19 How many players that we drafted this year will make significant contributions (either as regular back ups, temp. starters or STers) to the 2008 team?
(A) 0-3
(B) 4-6
(C) 7-10

#20 How many players that we drafted this year will make the active roster?
(A) 0-3
(B) 4-6
(C) 7-10
EXTRA: How many in your opinion will be on the practice squad?

Thats a hard question to answer, I think some of our later DB/S picks will help considering how big the dropoff is after the starters.

#21 What do you expect to get out of the draft (you can pick more than one)
(A) Mostly Starters in 2008
(B) Depth/STers
(C) Future Starters in 2009 and beyond
(D) Busts

#22 Do you feel that the Skins will be able to address needs via UDFA post-draft?
(A) Yes
(B) No
(C) Undecided

[cathartic-j]

#1. In your opinion what is/was the Skins biggest need pre-draft- choose only one:
(A) WR

#2. In your opinion do you Feel the Redskins addressed the biggest need during the draft?
(A) Yes

#3. Based on the limited FAs available and the final selections during the draft do you think the Skins should have gone after more FAs?
(B) No

#4. Did you feel the Skins put the draft picks to good use?
(A) Yes

#6 When we made the pick for Devin Thomas what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy

#6a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy

#7 When we made the pick for Fred Davis what was your inital reaction?
(B) Unhappy

#7a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy

#8 When we made the pick for Malcolm Kelly what was your inital reaction?
(C) Undecided

#8a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy

#9 When we made the pick for Chad Rhinehart what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy

#9a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy

#10 When we made the pick for JT Tyron what was your inital reaction?
(A) Happy

#10a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy

#11 When we made the pick for Durant Brooks what was your inital reaction?
(C) Undecided

#11a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy

#12 When we made the pick for Kareem Moore what was your inital reaction?
(C) Undecided

#12a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(A) Happy

#13 When we made the pick for Colt Brennan what was your inital reaction?
(C) Undecided

#13a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(C) Undecided

#14 When we made the pick for Rob Jackson what was your inital reaction?
(B) Unhappy

#14a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(B) Unhappy

#15 When we made the pick for Chris Horton what was your inital reaction?
(C) Undecided

#15a After doing some research, hearing media comments or reading ES what is your current opinion of the pick
(C) Undecided

#16 Were you happy with the outcome of this years draft?
(A) Yes

#17 Were you happy with the FO moves during the draft and how we used the picks?
(A) Yes, Completely Happy

#18 How many players that we drafted will be starters in the future in your opinion?
(B) 4-6

#19 How many players that we drafted this year will make significant contributions (either as regular back ups, temp. starters or STers) to the 2008 team?
(A) 0-3
(B) 4-6

#20 How many players that we drafted this year will make the active roster?
(A) 0-3
(B) 4-6

EXTRA: How many in your opinion will be on the practice squad?
2?

#21 What do you expect to get out of the draft (you can pick more than one)
(B) Depth/STers
(C) Future Starters in 2009 and beyond

#22 Do you feel that the Skins will be able to address needs via UDFA post-draft?
(A) Yes