PDA

View Full Version : Gaza relief boat damaged in encounter with Israeli vessel



The Brave Little Toaster Oven
December-30th-2008, 11:09 AM
http://edition.cnn.com/2008/WORLD/meast/12/30/gaza.aid.boat/?iref=hpmostpop


(CNN) -- An Israeli patrol boat struck a boat carrying medical volunteers and supplies to Gaza early Tuesday as it attempted to intercept the vessel in the Mediterranean Sea, witnesses and Israeli officials said.

CNN Correspondent Karl Penhaul was aboard the 60-foot, Gibraltar-registered pleasure boat Dignity when the contact occurred. When the boat later docked in the Lebanese port city of Tyre, severe damage was visible to the forward port side of the boat, and the front left window and part of the roof had collapsed.

The Dignity was carrying crew and 16 passengers -- physicians from Britain, Germany and Cyprus and human rights activists, including former U.S. Rep. Cynthia McKinney -- who were trying to reach Gaza through an Israeli blockade of the territory.

The captain of the Dignity said the Israelis broadcast a radio message accusing the vessel of being involved in terrorist activity. But Israeli Foreign Ministry spokesman Yigal Palmor denied that and said the radio message simply warned the vessel not to proceed to Gaza because it is a closed military area.

Palmor said there was no response to the radio message, and the vessel then tried to out-maneuver the Israeli patrol boat, leading to the collision. VideoWatch Penhaul describe the boat damage »

Penhaul said at least two Israeli patrol boats had shadowed the Dignity for about half an hour before the collision, moving around the vessel on all sides. One of the patrol boats then shined its spotlight on the Dignity while the other, with its lights off, "very severely rammed" the boat.

The captain of the Dignity told Penhaul he received no prior warning. Only after the collision did the Israelis come on the radio to say they struck the boat because they believed it was involved in terrorist activities. VideoWatch the chaos in Gaza and Israel »

The captain and crew said their vessel was struck intentionally, Penhaul said, but Palmor called those allegations "absurd."

"There is no intention on the part of the Israeli navy to ram anybody," Palmor said.

"I would call it ramming. Let's just call it as it is," McKinney said. "Our boat was rammed three times, twice in the front and one on the side. VideoWatch Cynthia McKinney discuss the collision »

"Our mission was a peaceful mission to deliver medical supplies and our mission was thwarted by the Israelis -- the aggressiveness of the Israeli military," she said.

The incident occurred in international waters about 90 miles off Gaza. Israel controls the waters off Gaza's coast and routinely blocks ships from coming into the Palestinian territory as part of an ongoing blockade that also applies to the Israel-Gaza border. Human rights groups have expressed concern about the blockade on Gaza, which has restricted the delivery of emergency aid and fuel supplies.

The collision was so severe, Penhaul said, that the passengers were ordered to put on their life vests and be ready to get in lifeboats. The Dignity began taking on water, but the crew managed to pump it out of the hull long enough for the boat to reach shore.

Palmor said the vessel refused assistance after the incident.

The boat was carrying boxes of relief supplies, volunteers and journalists to Gaza, the Palestinian territory now subject to an intense Israeli bombing campaign.

Israel launched airstrikes against Gaza on Saturday in what Defense Minister Ehud Barak called an "all-out war" against the Palestinian militant group Hamas, which has ruled the territory since 2007.

The Palestinian death toll has topped 375, most of them Hamas militants, Palestinian medical sources said Tuesday. At least 60 civilians have been killed in Gaza, U.N. officials said.

Hamas has responded with volleys of rocket fire aimed at southern Israeli towns, which have left six Israelis dead -- five of them civilians.

Hamas has vowed to defend Gaza in the face of what it calls continued Israeli aggression. Each side blames the other for violating an Egyptian-brokered cease-fire, which formally expired December 19 but had been weakening for months.

:wtf: was that nutbag doing trying to get to Gaza with medical supplies during all this? Isnt she anti-Israel too?

Destino
December-30th-2008, 11:23 AM
So they rammed it and claimed it was an accident? hilarious.

JohnLockesGhost
December-30th-2008, 11:31 AM
Well that's why they call it a blockade, Cynthia.

TrumanB
December-30th-2008, 11:39 AM
I wonder if she looked like this when the boat was getting rammed:

http://prudenceponder.files.wordpress.com/2008/01/cynthia_mckinney.jpg

pjfootballer
December-30th-2008, 11:56 AM
This is the beginning of a major war there. It's getting bad and I think Palestine loses.

Mad Mike
December-30th-2008, 12:34 PM
Lets see, unmarked boat sneaking into a war zone... What did they think was going to happen?

Teller
December-30th-2008, 01:18 PM
Lets see, unmarked boat sneaking into a war zone... What did they think was going to happen?

Nah, that ain't it. Them 'sraeli's is racist. ;)

Prosperity
December-30th-2008, 01:21 PM
it was probably giving them wmd's

sacase
December-30th-2008, 01:25 PM
She is not to bright, but then again she has always hated the Israeli's and loved arabs and their money.

Larry
December-30th-2008, 01:25 PM
Lets see, unmarked boat sneaking into a war zone... What did they think was going to happen?

At night. Wonder if their lights were on.

"No doubt some local fisherman, out for a pleasure cruise, at night, in eel-infested waters".

SkinInsite
December-30th-2008, 01:37 PM
At least they got off better than the USS Liberty.

Destino
December-30th-2008, 01:48 PM
Lets see, unmarked boat sneaking into a war zone... What did they think was going to happen?

What are you talking about it was an accident! You don't believe them?

Chump Bailey
December-30th-2008, 01:55 PM
She is not to bright

That's an understatement.

Skins24
December-30th-2008, 03:03 PM
So they rammed it and claimed it was an accident? hilarious.
?
Who claimed it was an accident?

Burgold
December-30th-2008, 03:06 PM
I feel terrible about that. They needed to fly a red cross flag or something. People risking their lives to help people should be honored not jeered at. I'm glad that they were not killed.

Ned Flanders
December-30th-2008, 03:07 PM
I think that Bush told the Israeli's that Cynthia McKinney was ON that boat, and THAT is why this happened.

Blame Bush! It's the easiest thing to do!

Burgold
December-30th-2008, 03:09 PM
Nah, you can't even blame Bush for the Palestinian/Israeli mess. They're too entrenched.

Redskins Diehard
December-30th-2008, 04:23 PM
This is the beginning of a major war there. It's getting bad and I think Palestine loses.


Palestine isn't the only loser when this happens...the good ol' US of A loses pretty big also.

Baculus
December-30th-2008, 04:43 PM
At least they got off better than the USS Liberty.

Yeah, that was my exact thought.

Baculus
December-30th-2008, 04:50 PM
I feel terrible about that. They needed to fly a red cross flag or something. People risking their lives to help people should be honored not jeered at. I'm glad that they were not killed.

I agree. But to some folks, if you decide to help the 'terrorists," which means anyone that is Palestinian, then you have signed your death warrant. You should have seen the right-wingers laughing and making jokes when that American protester was run over by an Israeli bulldozer in Palestine.

If this boat would have been sunk with these volunteers and Mckinney, they would have been doing back flips of joy.

Anyone that helps Hamas should be condemned, but it seems to be forgotten that a lot of people are suffering in the Gaza strip: Dirt poor people who are stuck in the middle of this war.

Larry
December-30th-2008, 04:58 PM
Anyone that helps Hamas should be condemned, but it seems to be forgotten that a lot of people are suffering in the Gaza strip: Dirt poor people who are stuck in the middle of this war.

Who elected Hamas as their officially empowered spokesmen to the world.

Baculus
December-30th-2008, 05:11 PM
Who elected Hamas as their officially empowered spokesmen to the world.

That much is true, but it isn't as if those Palestinians are the most educated electorate in the world, are they? Sure, folks have to take responsibilities for their decisions, but I don't think that means they should be condemned to death for it. Perhaps this will serve as a sort of lesson to the sort of leaders that they should elect...similar to our lessons here in the US.

Some of the voters were frustrated with Fatah and issues of corruption, which won votes for Hamas. Even within Hamas itself there are moderate elements who haven't been too happy with the more aggressive Hamas leadership.

Like any region, there are complexities to their politics, and every action take by the government isn't always in the best interest of their people.

This recent fighting may result in no change of the status quo, a collapse of Hamas in Gaza, or a strengthening in their position. But even before this recent spate of violence, Hamas was already in poor shape, so the missile attacks may be desperation to seek sympathy or to demonstrate that they are a "resistance group."

At least in my two-bit opinion. :-)

Destino
December-30th-2008, 05:26 PM
?
Who claimed it was an accident?

from the article:


The captain and crew said their vessel was struck intentionally, Penhaul said, but Palmor called those allegations "absurd."

"There is no intention on the part of the Israeli navy to ram anybody," Palmor said.

Larry
December-30th-2008, 05:44 PM
from the article:


The captain and crew said their vessel was struck intentionally, Penhaul said, but Palmor called those allegations "absurd."

"There is no intention on the part of the Israeli navy to ram anybody," Palmor said.


Oh, I don't think they intentionally rammed the ship.

That's what guns are for.

twa
December-30th-2008, 06:09 PM
Oh, I don't think they intentionally rammed the ship.

That's what guns are for.

Quite right,no need to muss up a perfectly good paint job.

Was it a woman driver?:D

Skins24
December-30th-2008, 07:04 PM
from the article:


The captain and crew said their vessel was struck intentionally, Penhaul said, but Palmor called those allegations "absurd."

"There is no intention on the part of the Israeli navy to ram anybody," Palmor said.

It may have not been their intention, but when it tried to out maneuver them I'm sure the Israelis didn't go out of their way to avoid any collision :)
Which is probably why they haven't stated it was just an accident...




I've seen a couple articles on this and I still haven't seen McKinney and Co. explain what exactly they were expecting. Did they honestly think an unmarked ship would just waltz up to a war zone uncontested?

Larry
December-30th-2008, 07:11 PM
I've seen a couple articles on this and I still haven't seen McKinney and Co. explain what exactly they were expecting. Did they honestly think an unmarked ship would just waltz up to a war zone uncontested?

From what I've read about McKinney, she probably believed exactly that.