ES 53 MAN ROSTER: Guard

[KDawg]

The original thread can be found here: http://extremeskins.com/showthread.php?t=307499

As usual, if I left someone off that you feel is deserving, please don't be afraid to vote for "other" and leave a post in this thread about who you want to vote for.

Another note: Players can make the team at more than one position. We will end this thing with 53 DIFFERENT players on the roster, so if a player makes it for two positions (or more) we will have a poll based on the top vote getters to re-vote on and see who gets the "wild card" spots.

CHOOSE TWO!!!!

1956-1958 Dick Stanfel
-3 seasons
-Appeared in 34 games, unknown number of starts.
-Pro Bowler in 1956, 1957, 1958
-ALL PRO in 1956, 1957, 1958

1960-1970 Vince Promuto
-11 seasons
-Appeared in 130 games, started in 56.
-Pro Bowler in 1963, 1964.
-Spent his entire career as a Washington Redskin.

1962-1964 John Nisby
-3 seasons
-Appeared in 42 games, unknown number of starts.
-Pro Bowler in 1962

1966-1975 Ray Schoenke
-10 seasons
-Appeared in 122 games, started in 64.

1970-1975 Paul Laaveg
-6 seasons
-Appeared in 72 games, started in 47.
-Spent his entire career as a Washington Redskin.

1981-1991 Russ Grimm
-11 seasons
-Appeared in 140 games, started in 114.
-Pro Bowler in 1983, 1984, 1985, 1986
-ALL PRO in 1983, 1984, 1985
-Spent his entire career as a Washington Redskin

1981-1989 Mark May
-9 seasons
-Appeared in 123 games, started in 115.
-Pro Bowler in 1988.

1985-1994 Raleigh McKenzie
-10 seasons
-Appeared in 144 games, started in 113.

1989-1994 Mark Schlereth
-6 seasons
-Appeared in 75 games, started in 59.
-Pro Bowler in 1991.

1989-1995, 2004-2005 Ray Brown
-8 seasons
-Appeared in 102 games, started in 70.

1994-2000, 2002 Tre' Johnson
-8 seasons
-Appeared in 90 games, started in 69.
-Pro Bowler in 1999.

2003-2008 Randy Thomas
-6 seasons
-Appeared in 80 games, started 80 games.

[KDawg]

Please vote for two, people :)

[suze109]

Grimm and May get my votes

[KDawg]

I went with Stanfel and Grimm. Hard to argue with two 3 time All-Pros. :)

[Capt'n Obvious]

I went with Russ Grimm and Mark May.

:logo:

[Old Bay]

Russ Grim. I meant to vote for Mark May, but Raleigh McKenzie got my vote instead due to a finger twitch. ;)

[pjfootballer]

Grimm is a no brainer. I took May by default. McKenzie would be my 3rd choice.

[scruffylookin]

I voted for Grimm (no brainer) and May.

Tough one on May because he did play alot of tackle too but I guess I've been influenced by the most recent Skins game I watched, at Atlanta in 1985 where the team ran for over 300 yards. Mark May was a freaking beast just killing guys.

[GhostofSparta]

Gee, Grimm is winning while getting everybody's vote. What are the odds?

My picks are Grimm and May.

[mcarey032]

Russ Grimm for sure and Mark May. Both those guys were instrumental in laying the ground work for offensive line and continuing it throughout our super bowl glory years.

[Gibbs Hog Heaven]

Childhood heroes Russ and Mark get the vote, not just for how good players and how integral a part of the Hogs they were right from the get go; but for what they meant to this franchise through the glory years.

It was hard to not have Rallo either for all the times he filled in and us never missing a beat. (Schlereth not so much. He turned into a prized dick when he left for Denver.).

Stanfel must of been one heck of a player though to be all-pro and go to the PB in all his three seasons.

Hail.

[KDawg]

Right now it's Grimm and May starting... McKenzie and Stanfel backing them up. That could change real fast, though!

Interesting that one person didn't vote for Grimm, though :)

[GhostofSparta]

Right now it's Grimm and May starting... McKenzie and Stanfel backing them up. That could change real fast, though!

Interesting that one person didn't vote for Grimm, though :)
I bet it was one of the Dallas fans....:chair:

[Annonymous Source]

Cmon people, lets get some votes for my main man RAY BROWN. He was in the league for over 20 years, and was a consistent force for most of that time.

RAY BROWN FOR HOF!!!

[KDawg]

We got a tie for the fourth roster spot between Stanfel and McKenzie still. I'd say Grimm is too far to be caught. May probably won't be caught but can. The last two spots are VERY much up for grabs.

[stevemcqueen1]

That's a lot of starts between Grimm, May, and McKenzie.

[WSHRedskins3ATLBraves3]

I voted for Grimm and May.

[KDawg]

Keep the votes coming. The third and fourth spots are still very much up for grabs.

[The Rook]

Glad to see Grimm and May as starters. Strange that May is listed as tackle on 70 greatest Reskins page. WTF

So I voted for the backups - Stanfel and McKenzie.







:helmet: The Rook

[SkinsNumberOne]

Unfortunately looks like a few people voted for more than 2.

[Leonard Washington]

i voted grimm and randy..he would fit in lovely with the hogs. i always thought may was a little mediocre.

[RenegadeTK]

Grimm & Stanfeld

[KDawg]

Holy cow this one is an absolute battle!