PDA

View Full Version : Wilbon(WP): Trade makes for a perfect fit



authentic
April-4th-2010, 10:30 PM
click for the rest (http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/04/04/AR2010040403463.html) :D


McNabb, for the record, didn't know until the last second where he was going to wind up. The rumors that the Vikings were atop his list were erroneous; McNabb told me that himself last week. The Raiders were a team that was interested, but not the only team. McNabb and I talked about the business of football the other night in Arizona, a totally off-the-record conversation. But I was reminded that night, with all due respect to Campbell, why McNabb is about the best fit around to be the quarterback of the Washington Redskins . . .

. . . Because Donovan McNabb has done most of it and seen all of it. Even on an evening when the Eagles, the only team he has played for, were trying to trade him, he was completely unfazed. We're talking about an 11-year veteran who was booed by Eagles fans from the moment he was selected. He's dealt with injury, the harshest criticism imaginable, idiot teammates such as Terrell Owens, roiled up locker rooms. He's watched his team draft his replacement, taken the field with few if any Pro Bowl-caliber weapons. He's shrugged off controversies involving race that were none of his doing. Yet, McNabb has always been able to speak his mind, keep his dignity and keep his team in Super Bowl contention.

McNabb is not only accustomed to the insanity of being a quarterback in the NFL, and the extra weight of being a black quarterback in the NFL, he laughs it off. It can't get to him, didn't even catch up to him when he was young. If you can survive playing quarterback in Philly, and lead the team to five NFC championships, then Washington ought to be a piece of cake. After a week or two in D.C., McNabb will wonder who turned down the volume.

The most important thing to the success of a franchise is having an established coach and quarterback, people with commanding presence. And the Redskins have that in this in Mike Shanahan and McNabb, something they haven't had since perhaps since Joe Gibbs and Mark Rypien.

He's as battle-tested a quarterback as could possibly have been available to the Washington Redskins right now. The silliness that passes for controversy in Washington will likely make Donovan McNabb smile . . . if not laugh out loud.

In a very brief conversation Sunday night after the trade, McNabb said he is "absolutely looking forward to this . . . absolutely. I'm excited about it, no question." There was a pause as he asked me about Campbell. "I need to get in touch with Jason, I need to hear his thoughts on all this . . . You know I really like Jason."

As do I, which is why I think this trade for McNabb and what I presume to be the imminent departure of restricted free agent Campbell, are just what both men and the franchise need. McNabb, it seems to me, will benefit from the change in scenery. I was agitating for the Arizona Cardinals, McNabb's hometown team because he has a home there, to do this the moment Kurt Warner retired, but they instead settled for Derek Anderson. The Chicago Bears, McNabb's real hometown team, should have gotten McNabb last off-season instead of giving up the farm for interception machine Jay Cutler; it would have been so much smarter. McNabb, at 33, isn't a long-term solution, but these days the smart teams play to win now, which is why the Jets and Vikings took a shot with old man Brett Favre. Look at the success Warner had with the Cardinals.

And I've hoped Campbell would leave the management-coaching dysfunction that undermined his career and find a professional situation. That could have happened with Shanahan now in charge. But Campbell, no matter how hurt he probably is now, should drop to his knees and feel his prayers have been answered. With McNabb and Rex Grossman here, the Redskins don't need Campbell anymore and couldn't possibly match an offer he got elsewhere.

bulldog
April-4th-2010, 10:35 PM
the Redskins will deal Campbell and recoup a draft pick for 2010, Jason will get the chance to start over somewhere else.

agreed, best outcome for everyone involved.

except for the Eagles, who I think may suffer more than they think at present.

Buck812
April-4th-2010, 10:37 PM
Wilbon is an idoit... Who would ever cheer for a trader? I would give any team our 1st to take him from us.

DarrellsMyHero28
April-4th-2010, 10:38 PM
Wilbon is an idoit... Who would ever cheer for a trader? I would give any team our 1st to take him from us.

Well you would be one of the worst GMs of all time.

Rdskns2000
April-4th-2010, 10:39 PM
the Redskins will deal Campbell and recoup a draft pick for 2010, Jason will get the chance to start over somewhere else.

agreed, best outcome for everyone involved.

except for the Eagles, who I think may suffer more than they think at present.

And whaT IS wrong with that. ;):D

aussieskin
April-4th-2010, 10:44 PM
This really above all shows that the skins are not the franchise we once were, this is a great signing, he can still play and he can teach once again the skins are on top and moving forward

BayouBrave86
April-4th-2010, 10:46 PM
A positive article from Wilbon? WTF?

flexxskins
April-4th-2010, 10:48 PM
Wilbon is an idoit... Who would ever cheer for a trader? I would give any team our 1st to take him from us.:ols:Did McNabb defect or something?

Get real.

Jumbo
April-4th-2010, 10:50 PM
the Redskins will deal Campbell and recoup a draft pick for 2010, Jason will get the chance to start over somewhere else.

agreed, best outcome for everyone involved.

except for the Eagles, who I think may suffer more than they think at present.

Without implying I know exactly how this will turn out (I think the move is perfectly supportable though I didn't predict it), it's nice to note that will all the typical spasmodic and overstated flailing there's also a slice of sanity available on the board...

LaRonDontLikeUgly
April-4th-2010, 10:52 PM
THIS is why I'm excited for 2010.


Campbell isn't good with insanity swirling around him, and perhaps will never be. McNabb is, and he knows it. So does everybody in the NFC East.

stoney26
April-4th-2010, 10:53 PM
This is just so surreal. I cant believe this has happened.

Buck812
April-4th-2010, 11:00 PM
:ols:Did McNabb defect or something?

Get real.


You know what.. I havent thought about the good side of this. Watching McPOS play behind our line could be fun... As brittle as he is he will get the worst ass beating of his life on opening day.. and it doesnt matter who we play

Can we get Romo and Ely too??? Line em up and let em get beat down... I would love that! lol

:ols::ols::ols::ols:

gatito
April-4th-2010, 11:01 PM
Wilbon simply has a hard on for Mcnabb. Always has and always will.

scruffylookin
April-4th-2010, 11:02 PM
Wilbon is wrong. This is a horrible move if we actually intend to keep McNabb. Good news is I don't think we are keeping him. I firmly believe this is a move to move up and get Bradford.

gatito
April-4th-2010, 11:05 PM
Without implying I know exactly how this will turn out (I think the move is perfectly supportable though I didn't predict it), it's nice to note that will all the typical spasmodic and overstated flailing there's also a slice of sanity available on the board...

Did you polish up your crystal ball and look into it so you could see the future?

I mean honestly no one knows how this is going to turn out yet. If McNabb plays at a pro bowl level in DC then we did great. If he craps the bed and turns into a drama queen and does not have Andy Reid to coddle him it will be another in a long line of poor trades of our future for someone's older vet.

At this point any position is supportable. You simply like some more than others but that does not make them right.

HailNatsSkinz
April-4th-2010, 11:07 PM
Wilbon is wrong. This is a horrible move if we actually intend to keep McNabb. Good news is I don't think we are keeping him. I firmly believe this is a move to move up and get Bradford.

Why would we trade our 2nd this year and a 3rd/4th next year for a QB only to try to package him to move up to the #1 overall pick with our 4th overall pick? Why wouldn't we just trade our 4th overall pick and the picks we used to get McNabb to move up? If the Rams wanted McNabb so bad, why didn't they just trade for him?

SkinsNoles21
April-4th-2010, 11:07 PM
Wilbon is an idoit... Who would ever cheer for a trader? I would give any team our 1st to take him from us.

Says the guy who doesnt understand the business side of football at all. Plus, it was time for Mcnabb to get out of Philly ...

Hubbs
April-4th-2010, 11:08 PM
Wilbon is an idoit... Who would ever cheer for a trader? I would give any team our 1st to take him from us.

This might be the strangest post I've seen in a day of some really strange posts.

Chicken Fried
April-4th-2010, 11:09 PM
The problem is that our team has too many holes to fill. We are not ready to go to the Super Bowl now just because we have McNabb. By the time we get the pieces assembled, McNabb will probably be 36-37 years old. Our chances don't look really good trying to get to the Super Bowl with a QB that old. He'll probably be great for a year or two, but what does that mean if the rest of the team isn't ready to play on his level? Some guys are ready like Cooley and Davis, but our RB corps and OL needs to be replenished significantly. Not to mention our Defense will probably be horrible this year as we change to a 3-4. This is not the time to get a great QB near the end of his productive years.

stevemcqueen1
April-4th-2010, 11:12 PM
This is just so surreal. I cant believe this has happened.

This is pretty much my feeling too. McNabb shouldn't be seen as much more than a bridge into a new era but he's one hell of a bridge. Plus he gives us something real to look forward to next season. I just can't believe the Eagles traded him to US. What if Kolb fails? Think of the tremendous pressure they just added to his job which already carried tremendous pressure. All for a high second round pick.

I will say the price we paid is astonishingly low when you consider what Charlie Whitehurst just got the Chargers.

s0crates
April-4th-2010, 11:12 PM
Read the whole article. Really. Wilbon does a great job describing McNabb. DMac is a guy who has been overcoming obstacles and proving people wrong his whole life. We needed a leader on offense, now we have one.

This guy knows the system, he knows the division, and he knows how to win in the NFL. I am really excited about having him here.

Warhead36
April-4th-2010, 11:13 PM
The only person who's dick Wilbon sucks harder than McNabb's is Tiger Woods's.

Truant
April-4th-2010, 11:17 PM
Why would we trade our 2nd this year and a 3rd/4th next year for a QB only to try to package him to move up to the #1 overall pick with our 4th overall pick? Why wouldn't we just trade our 4th overall pick and the picks we used to get McNabb to move up? If the Rams wanted McNabb so bad, why didn't they just trade for him?

The Eagles didn't want to send McNabb to an abyss like St. Louis and we were the highest bidder.

I'm holding out hope as well that we don't have that douche bag as our QB. He refuses to use his mobility. He's under a 60% passer for his career. Campbell's QB rating last year is close to McNabb's... and we all know about the talent on the line, at WR, and at RB we had last year.

Wilbon is a clown. He loves his Chicago boy McNabb. Warner was able to play well into his 30s because of his accuracy. Even in AZ, with a downfield passing game, his accuracy was still better than McNabb's. And a comparison to Farve? Not a chance. Look at the career stats. Better than average, but great by no means.

Ghost of Nibbs McPimpin
April-4th-2010, 11:18 PM
You know what.. I havent thought about the good side of this. Watching McPOS play behind our line could be fun... As brittle as he is he will get the worst ass beating of his life on opening day.. and it doesnt matter who we play


Looking at your posts tonight, I can't believe I wasted time exchanging ideas with you on QB/O-Line, etc.

Of course, it never quite seeps through your thick skull that this interest in QB by Shanahans might mean they think the biggest weakness is THERE not at line (or at least the biggest and HARDEST to fix.)

BTW, we know what's up on Wilbon, it's just a shame he's so transparent. On a positive note, this should make certain posters feel better since they have evinced a fairly similar attitude to Wilbon's.

s0crates
April-4th-2010, 11:21 PM
The only person who's **** Wilbon ***** harder than McNabb's is Tiger Woods's.I would not post such things if I were you.

Jimbo
April-4th-2010, 11:25 PM
If the Rams wanted McNabb so bad, why didn't they just trade for him?

Because he would not accept a trade to any team but the Skins. He strong-armed the Iggs and when we offered the conditional pick next year, Andy Reid jumped on it because it was pretty much the only choice he had.

SAli457180
April-4th-2010, 11:30 PM
I wholeheartedly agree with Wilbon. Both QBs need a change a change of scenery. McNabb did so much for the Eagles and the fans still gave him a ton of BS. The Philly faithful can have Kevin Kolb and we'll see if he can accomplish anything close to what McNabb did. Campbell needs to move on and he himself has endured a ton of grief. He may have potential, but it didn't materialize here.

gatito
April-4th-2010, 11:31 PM
I wholeheartedly agree with Wilbon. Both QBs need a change a change of scenery. McNabb did so much for the Eagles and the fans still gave him a ton of BS. The Philly faithful can have Kevin Kolb and we'll see if he can accomplish anything close to what McNabb did. Campbell needs to move on and he himself has endured a ton of grief. He may have potential, but it didn't materialize here.

Slurp......LOL

angel2
April-4th-2010, 11:34 PM
Wilbon is wrong. This is a horrible move if we actually intend to keep McNabb. Good news is I don't think we are keeping him. I firmly believe this is a move to move up and get Bradford.




You could be right, but I am LMAO at your comment. Why would you go from Campbell to a no experience rookie? You are one funny poster.

SAli457180
April-4th-2010, 11:38 PM
Slurp......LOL

Whatever. There are times when Wilbon makes sense and IMO, this is one of them.