What do you expect for trading Campbell?

[addicted]

If we trade Jason Campbell to another team what do you expect to receive in compensation for him? What's the general consensus and feeling about this? Poll posted, please vote. Thanks

[thecardiacrll]

I would say a 5th.

[fdarugar]

An early 4th rounder.

[Jumbo]

The only thing that will keep this from being closed and the OP NNT'ed will be the quick appearance of a poll, and even that is being kind. :)

[addicted]

The only thing that will keep this from being closed and the OP NNT'ed will be the quick appearance of a poll, and even that is being kind. :)

Poll posted

[santana_4_prez]

I said 4th, but what I really mean is a 4th and something else...like a 4th and a 6th or something.

[SKIN4WAHOOZ]

what it is

[Jumbo]

Poll posted

Well done, and a fine poll it is---breathe freely :ols:

[addicted]

Well done, and a fine poll it is---breathe freely :ols:

Heh :ols:

[Passizle]

I think a 3rd is not unreasonable. That, or a combination of later picks... fourth and fifth... fourth and sixth... etc...

[cyfar]

A 4th rounder would be sufficient, but a 3rd rounder would be awesome.

[Tay]

I said 3rd, but thats just because of the Oak tease. I would like a 4th at the very least though

[Laxpunk2006]

I think a third is reasonable. Worse QB's with worse resume has garnered seconds (AJ Feely anyone? injured Culpepper?) but we killed any leverage we had with the McNabb trade.

Luckily there are a few QB needy teams like Buffalo, Oakland, Carolina, etc. that could use a veteran and they're all teams that like to pound the ball and run play-action.

He surely isn't elite but he isn't a bad QB either, he's mediocre. Even finding a mediocre QB in this league can be difficult so he has value to a number of teams.

[Gibbs Hog Heaven]

We've seen his league wide worth last off-season and now this, so I'm expecting little.

I'd be overjoyed with a 5th. If we can somehow swindle Al Davis out of a 3rd/4th, I'ma proclaiming Allen as the new GM messiah.

Hail.

[Oldskool]

At best a late 3rd round pick, but probably a 5th.

[dfbovey]

4th rounder seems realistic.

[Justsomeguy]

He is a valuable backup so they better acquire a good pick for him, otherwise he is more valuable as a redskin.

[GibbsFactor]

I want the highest possible. But in reality I expect a 5th rounder, hopefully 4th.

[HigSkin]

4th until there are more teams seeking his services. If it's just Oakland and Buffalo, per Clayton, that's a bad thing for pick position.

[jsharrin55]

I am hopeful for a 4th and 5th. Maybe 4th and a conditional 2011 pick. I think there are a few 4th/5th round guys that could help us and JC is a low 3rd/high 4th value guy IMO.

[Braxford]

Would love to somehow get Al Davis to agree to a 2nd rounder for JC. I would not let him go for less than a 4th though with a conditional pick next year. So I split the middle and say 3rd.

[StillUnknown]

given what some other no name qb's have gotten, i'd be disappointed if we got less than a 4th for him

with no leverage though, it'll be hard to even get a 4th

[ciresolstice]

I want a 3rd but expect a 4th.

[Renegade7]

4th or a 5th, in which case I'd rather keep him in DC whether he likes it or not...

[WSHRedskins3ATLBraves3]

I think it will be a 4th or a 5th if he gets moved.

[boofMcboof]

No ham sammich option?

[Santana_89]

I voted 5th round, it'd be a wonderful surprise if it was a higher pick.

[GhostofSparta]

I'd love to see a player-for-player swap where we get an O-lineman. Something like JC to the Rams for Alex Barron (?). Maybe to another team that needs a QB but has a RFA lineman they're not looking hard at re-signing.

[Jim Bob]

http://espn.go.com/blog/nfceast/post/_/id/12977/how-does-clausen-affect-campbells-status

With the 2010 draft and guys like Clausen & Tebow potentially affecting which teams will have an interest in Campbell, my guess is that he might go for a 2011 pick(s) that are conditional on what Campbell does for his new team in 2010 and if he signs an extension.

[Drastik]

Anything less than a 3rd and we are coming up on the short end of the trade.... so I'd say a 3rd.

[XxSpearheadxX]

I want the highest possible. But in reality I expect a 5th rounder, hopefully 4th.

[nebster21]

IF Santonio Holmes a Superbowl MVP gets traded for a 5th. Than I think we get a half eaten candy bar for JC or maybe the option to pick up an undrafted free agent.

[Archangel1750]

I voted other. I say couple trading JC and AH to Tampa Bay for their #3 overall pick.

[unculver]

I say JC for Marshawn Lynch, JC wants out and so does lynch, we need a young RB and they need a upgrade at Qb

[unculver]

Or even JC, AH, Fred Davis to rams for #1 and a 2nd or 3rd rounder.

[Jim Bob]

Anything less than a 3rd and we are coming up on the short end of the trade.... so I'd say a 3rd.

Seriously?

McNabb cost the Redskins a 2nd & a future conditional pick.

Campbell's trade value is nowhere near what McNabb's was.

[Jim Bob]

I say JC for Marshawn Lynch, JC wants out and so does lynch, we need a young RB and they need a upgrade at Qb

I live in Western NY and I wouldn't touch Lynch with a 10 foot pole.

He's had a whole bunch of off the field issues. Plus, the Bills roster is worse than the Redskins right now. If JC goes to Buffalo, I'm hoping for picks.

About the only guy on the Bills roster I'd want is untouchable - Paul Posluszny.

[Jim Bob]

Or even JC, AH, Fred Davis to rams for #1 and a 2nd or 3rd rounder.

Have you been waking and baking with Santonio Holmes?

There is no way the Rams give up a shot at Bradford PLUS another pick for that package.

[Jim Bob]

I voted other. I say couple trading JC and AH to Tampa Bay for their #3 overall pick.

I can't see Tampa Bay making that deal.

They might give the Redskins a 2nd or 3rd rounder for that package, though.

Everyone knows that Campbell and Haynesworth are on the outs here. That means that they are on clearance sale and teams will lowball the Redskins.

Just look at the Steelers getting a 5th rounder for a former SB MVP WR!

Beggars can't be choosers.

[jasjhughes]

want a third, but expect a fourth. For a fifth I'd probably just keep him.

[flexxskins]

I picked 3rd.

BTW this is a good idea for a thread/poll addicted and long overdue.:applause:

[dadirtbags]

I think our best bet is to package two or more players for a few picks...otherwise...we will be lucky to get Campbell for one of Al Davis's cuban cigars

[TheLongshot]

I'm still going with my pick: a 4th and a conditional pick next year. I think the team really wants to get 3rd round value at minimum for Campbell.

[SonnyJ]

Excellent athletic skills. Big arm. Coachable. Hard worker. A lot of starting experience in the NFL.

Sounds like something pretty valuable.

You look at the other side of the ledger, though.

Slow decision-maker. Struggles picking up new offenses. Poor defensive recognition. Holds the ball. Poor downfield accuracy. Conservative to a fault. Abysmal record as a starter. Outplayed by career backup.

There's scant interest in the guy, unfortunately. Someone mentioned that he has a better resume than guys like Feeley. That actually works against Campbell - there's a large body of work on which to judge Campbell, and the judgment isn't flattering. Feeley got about 5 games and led the Eagles well during that time - his limited exposure made him more attractive than he actually was. If he had been given 50+ starts, there would not have been much of a market for him, either.

Campbell is Ramsey, Part II, so I'll say a sixth rounder for a team looking for a backup.

[Chump Bailey]

Two first rounders minimum

[artmonkforHOF]

I picked other, as I don't think we will get anything for him. He will be released and picked up after the draft.

Say you are the Raiders or the Bills or some other team interested in signing JC. You would not sign him as a RFA and give up the first round pick, and you know Washington is going to want to dump him before camp, so why even make an offer now? You loose a draft pick to get a guy who might not even want to play for your team. A team interested in Campbell will wait until they can sign him as a UFA, there is no need to trade for a guy that most likely will be released, and I don't think any team is sold that JC is their "must have guy" so there is no need to trade a draft pick for him.

If they wanted to trade JC, it should have been done before acquiring McNabb.

[jsharrin55]

I am hopeful for a 4th and 5th. Maybe 4th and a conditional 2011 pick. I think there are a few 4th/5th round guys that could help us and JC is a low 3rd/high 4th value guy IMO.

I see Oak has 2 5th rounders. I could live with that too.

[Mr_ Skinshead]

Other: A 25% discount on a 2010 McNabb Jersey

[JetSkins]

Everyone saying 3rd rounder is dreaming. 'Skins have zero leverage here

[Sndman8369]

If we could get a 6th rounder this year and a 3rd rounder next year, that would be great. That could maybe entice a team like Oakland of Buffalo to make the deal, not having to give up anything valuable till next year.......just wishful thinking

[RandyHolt]

some sort of walking clock

Joking aside, a 4th.

[SkinsCrushCowboys]

..him to stay as a back up and see what happens with the potential strike or agreement after the end of next season....Donovanprobably will not sign an extension until some of the barg agreement is worked out....if he goes, I would think a late 3 or 4 would be on the table.

[gorebd82]

I see Oak has 2 5th rounders. I could live with that too.

Actually, their 4th (8) and the later 5th (27) sounds fair.

[gorebd82]

I thought about it some more and I wonder if we could do a swap for Gradkowski. Maybe Gradkowski and a 5th. Jason had a 1st round tender and Bruce had a 2nd round tender. I think we can let him and Grossman compete to be Donovan's backup. This might help as develop a new Todd Collins type for the new regime.

[stevemcqueen1]

Nothing less than a 3rd this year. Anything less would be awful value. Just keep him for a year as a backup. Sage Rosenfels got traded four a 4th round pick, we need to be shooting for more than that.

What we need to do is wait until after the draft to trade him and try and deal him for a 2011 second. That's worth more to us than a crappy late pick this year.

[stevemcqueen1]

I picked other, as I don't think we will get anything for him. He will be released and picked up after the draft.

Say you are the Raiders or the Bills or some other team interested in signing JC. You would not sign him as a RFA and give up the first round pick, and you know Washington is going to want to dump him before camp, so why even make an offer now? You loose a draft pick to get a guy who might not even want to play for your team. A team interested in Campbell will wait until they can sign him as a UFA, there is no need to trade for a guy that most likely will be released, and I don't think any team is sold that JC is their "must have guy" so there is no need to trade a draft pick for him.

If they wanted to trade JC, it should have been done before acquiring McNabb.

We're not going to cut him or dump him before camp. Do you really think Colt Brennan is going to make the roster before Campbell? At any rate, Campbell is a better backup than Grossman and I wouldn't be surprised if we kept him and he got some PT. McNabb is injury prone, we're not going to go into the season with a crappy backup if we can help it. Even if we draft a QB, I could see the FO keeping Campbell around as a 4th QB and our primary backup.

[No Excuses]

A 4th for this year and conditional pick for next year.

[TheMan CC47]

I think the most we could hope for is having to give our 4th round pick to which ever teams takes him off our hands.

[Rdskns2000]

I would love a 3rd or 2nd rounder. Chances of that happening are slim. I think 4th rounder is realistic.

[Travdaskin]

A 4th for this year and conditional pick for next year.

This...

[stevemcqueen1]

I think the most we could hope for is having to give our 4th round pick to which ever teams takes him off our hands.

Man that's HILARIOUS!!!!!1!

[lavarisgone]

JC and AH to the Bills for their First and Sixth rounders.

[Veretax]

I would expect a 2nd Round pick, or a third plus something else...He may not be McNabb but he does have starter experience

[styx491]

A 4th for this year and conditional pick for next year.

I agree. That could turn into O-Line and maybe a RB.

[angel2]

If we trade Jason Campbell to another team what do you expect to receive in compensation for him? What's the general consensus and feeling about this? Poll posted, please vote. Thanks



A box of Washington State apples and a pickle. Are you serious?

What team in their right mind would give up picks for him?

[thomasroane]

If Allen gets a three for JC he should be given a raise and an extension on the spot! Sadly, I think a lot of you are over-valuing JC just cause he was picked in the first round. Remember our dirty little secret; a large % of JC's stats came when the game was already decided.

[Redskins4ever]

I would like to see the Redskins get at least a 3rd round pick. But I think Bruce Allen will get either a 4th rounder, or a 4th and 5th rounders for Campbell.

[texasthunder]

I am wishing for a second rounder, but would be happy with a third.

[That Redskins Fan]

Wish for a fourth

reality fifth or sixth

[HailfrmDEN]

Everybody to forget about campbell.

[Forever21]

I think best case scenario we get lucky and get an early third rounder.

Worst case scenario we get a 5th.

I think it'll be 4th although I'd love for it to be a 3rd.

I am keeping my fingers crossed that Allen and Shanahan find a way to scam Oakland out of their 2nd.

[hailskins11]

My heart tells me we can get a 2nd. My head says 4th or Al Davis someone for a 3rd.

[TE#80]

This...

^^^This... word gets on my nerves.

[Forever21]

I would expect a 2nd Round pick, or a third plus something else...He may not be McNabb but he does have starter experience

Really? A 2nd rounder? I love your optimism!

[jelsis]

I voted 6th but I would take a bag of footballs for him!:beatdeadhorse:

[Main-Maine]

Not after this Holmes trade. I think the value just went way down for Campbell. I think if anything we might get a next year conditional pick of a 5th(if he does good) or a 7th.

[Forever21]

Not after this Holmes trade. I think the value just went way down for Campbell. I think if anything we might get a next year conditional pick of a 5th(if he does good) or a 7th.

The Holmes deal has extrenuating circumstances though. Character and suspensions and even Big Ben is a factor I think. You can't use that trade as a litmus test for Campbell's value.

[redskinsgod]

LOL. Who are the 54 people who said they would expect a first or second round pick for campbell? Man, what games were they watching the last few year? If anything, I wouldn't be surprised to see a 4th thru 6th at best. Why would you give up more with a career backup on your hands?

[theMEAST21]

I think that 2nd and possibly 3rd round picks straight up are out of the question at this point, but i could packaging the 4th overall with campbell and taking somewhere in the 10-15 range and picking up a second.

I think that would be best case scenario and hard to pull off but if we did that we could still get a solid OT and possibly get a NT or OG with the second we pick up...

[Bootleg]

The results are in.

[addicted]

I started this thread and voted 7th round pick. Since we got the 4th round pick 2 years from now for him, what does that really make that pick worth? I ask because it's conventional wisdom to think that if you take a player this year and trade a pick the next year you have to go up a round. For example if you trade for a 2nd rounder this year it will cost you your 1st rounder next year. So does that mean Cample for a 4th in 2012 is actually a 6th rounder? Anyone know how that works out? Seems really unusual to me to trade a draft pick 2 years from now

[IHOPSkins]

Wish for a fourth

reality fifth or sixthThe Winner......Nice call

4th rounder in 2 YEARS

Go Unleash that "Inner Dragon" Someplace else JC

[revallenjr]

I will go out on a limb and say a 2012 4th round pick.

[Spear]

This thread proves that people on this board have no idea what players are worth in trade. It's no wonder so many get mad on draft day -- in their minds, we could have traded down 8 times and gotten king's ransoms for all our unwanted players. It just doesn't work that way.

[wvtbred]

When you have an incompetent front office that devalues it players with their action and inaction you deserve what you get.

Campbell is supposed to be so worthless yet he will probably be the starter the moment camp opens.

If he does he isn't beating much, a 290 lb so called qb and an injured one. What was incompetent was the QB not everything else like some of you want us to believe.

[Park City Skins]

I think this one has played itself out.