6 future pitchers to the Hall.

[fanofnobody]

Mike Mussina
Randy Johnson
Curt Shilling
Greg Maddux
Pedro Martinez
Tom Glavine


Are all these pitchers Hall of Fame locks? If not what do you think their chances are on a scale of 1-10

Mike Mussina-7
Randy Johnson-9.5
Curt Shilling-8
Greg Maddux-LOCK
Pedro Martinez-8.5
Tom Glavine-5

[SlickNick]

Originally posted by fanofnobody
Mike Mussina
Randy Johnson
Curt Shilling
Greg Maddux
Pedro Martinez
Tom Glavine


Are all these pitchers Hall of Fame locks? If not what do you think their chances are on a scale of 1-10

Mike Mussina-7
Randy Johnson-9.5
Curt Shilling-8
Greg Maddux-LOCK
Pedro Martinez-8.5
Tom Glavine-5


moose - needs to win close to 300 since he has not been as dominant as RJ

RJ - definite lock, top 3 lefties of all time

Glavine - no

pedro - yes, if he can hold up for a few more stat filling seasons

schilling - great yes, but the #'s just are'nt there

maddux - definitely


:high: :tongue:

[TheDoyler23]

Maddux, Pedro and Johnson are in..the rest belong in the hall of 'very good'

[galentjm]

Unless he wins another 100 games Mussina is never going to be in the HOF. He's never won a Cy Young, never had a single 20 win season, and his career ERA of 3.54 is not dominating by any stretch of the imagination. He'll go done as one the better pitchers of his time, however not deserving of enshrinement.

I think Glavine will get in. He's not a dominating pitcher, but he just wins. He's won more games that Randy Johnson, and statistically is one of the best lefties of all time. He gets my vote, for what its worth.

[Rypien 91]

Isn't Glavine close to 300 wins? Does that make him a lock then?

[SlickNick]

253, and it doesnt look like his arm is going to hold up for the 3 more years he would need to reach 300 - and thats being generous.

:high: