Brady vs. Manning

[Coltsalr]

I've only seen this discussed between Patriots and Colts fans.

I'd be interested in seeing other fans discuss it.

HAVE AT IT

Once we get some opinions flowing I'll drop in my two cents, but for now, I'll just say I say Manning.

[Spaceman Spiff]

Brady, and it's not even close. He teabags Manning on a repeated basis.

[bubba9497]

Manning

hands down

[sableholic]

I've only seen this discussed between Patriots and Colts fans.

I'd be interested in seeing other fans discuss it.

HAVE AT IT

Once we get some opinions flowing I'll drop in my two cents, but for now, I'll just say I say Manning.

Are you serious? You've never seen this discussed before besides between Pats and Colts fans?

Anyways Manning is the better QB

[Who Del]

Stats? Manning.

Supes? Brady.

Who will be remembered more? Brady. 3 Supes? Come on. I can't even believe this is a debate.

[dfos81]

Gotta go w/ Brady, how many superbowls will this guy end up w/? He is just cool as cucumber under pressure, alot like Montana.

[bubba9497]

Stats? Manning.

Supes? Brady.

Who will be remembered more? Brady. 3 Supes? Come on. I can't even believe this is a debate.

Manning isn't done yet

[dfos81]

Manning isn't done yet

Neither is Brady imho, have you seen the Pats this offseason? I know its hard to win a superbowl in the offseason, but the Pats could do it again, and then where would you rank Brady? 4 superbowls is ridiculous for any Qb/team these days in the nfl.

[bubba9497]

Neither is Brady imho, have you seen the Pats this offseason? I know its hard to win a superbowl in the offseason, but the Pats could do it again, and then where would you rank Brady? 4 superbowls is ridiculous for any Qb/team these days in the nfl.

I doubt it

[Coltsalr]

Gotta go w/ Brady, how many superbowls will this guy end up w/? He is just cool as cucumber under pressure, alot like Montana.

You mean like how he's thrown game-clinching interceptions against Denver, San Diego, and Indianapolis?

That's three out of his last four playoff games.

Personally, I think he's lost his swagger when it comes to pressure.

[Coltsalr]

Can anyone imagine if Manning would've had the defenses that Brady has had all these years? Would it have even been close?

[Coltsalr]

In case nobody's noticed, Brady ranked #9 in NFL Passer Rating last year.

Who was number one? Manning.

It would not be a stretch, in my opinion, to say that Brady could be declining.

[Symbol]

I'll say it like this, both QB's will and should be in the Hall Of Fame one day. As for who's best, I'll say Manning is in the regular season, stats wise and Brady is in the post season.

Overall, which would I want if I were to be the HC of a team, Peyton Manning. I think Marvin Harrison is one of the best wide receivers in the game today, because of Peyton. Brady does the same with less talent, but I believe that Manning has the better arm in both arm strength and accuracy.

Plus, and this is props to Bang, his monkey is now on Eli's back and not his own.

[bubba9497]

In case nobody's noticed, Brady ranked #9 in NFL Passer Rating last year.

Who was number one? Manning.

It would not be a stretch, in my opinion, to say that Brady could be declining.

did you know .......



Romo 95 Rating

[dfos81]

I doubt it

You doubt the Pats can win another SB w/ Brady? ok. I doubt Manning will get as many as Brady, what about you?