ExtremeSkins FF Dynasty League

[stoshuaj]

k, I pulled up scoring from an old league on Yahoo.

DT/ST:
Sack (1)
Interception (2)
Fumble Recovery (2)
Touchdown (6)
Safety (2)
Block Kick (2)
Kickoff and Punt Return Touchdowns (6)
Points Allowed 0 points (15)
Points Allowed 1-6 points (10)
Points Allowed 7-13 points (6)
Points Allowed 14-20 points (3)
Points Allowed 21-27 points (0)
Points Allowed 28-34 points (-3)
Points Allowed 35+ points (-6)

IDP:
Tackle Solo (1)
Sack (2)
Interception (3)
Fumble Force (3)
Fumble Recovery (2)
Touchdown (6)
Safety (2)
Pass Defended (1)
Block Kick (2)

not saying it's right or wrong, just giving an example

[Touchdown Redskins]

I think we should make the numbers be the same for D/ST and IDP (except for awarding D/ST tackle points). So I would say:

1 point per tackle (assisted or solo, same for each)
1 point per sack (this may have some contention, but is a sack other than a tackle for loss?)
2 points per RECOVERED fumble and INT
3 points per blocked kick (because they're so rare)

What do you guys think?

Edit:

Also, safety should be 3 points (because they're so rare), and passes defended should be 1 point.

[kuraitengai]

OUCH!...you bastage...



Good point. If we wait til the start of round 9, then I think any changes made are fair to everyone.

i may be a bastage, but at least im not a festing bastage.......you anal dwelling butt monkey.

yeah, i picked 9 cuz it was the end of the current round, and i wasnt planning on going with any D picks until 12...

oh wait...that doesnt make any sense....hah, i fool you.

[stoshuaj]

I just looked, Chu was the last pick....that'd be pretty tight to not let him make a change if that's really what he wants to do. (and no, I don't want Henry.....)

[stoshuaj]

I think we should make the numbers be the same for D/ST and IDP (except for awarding D/ST tackle points). So I would say:

1 point per tackle (assisted or solo, same for each)
1 point per sack (this may have some contention, but is a sack other than a tackle for loss?)
2 points per RECOVERED fumble and INT
3 points per blocked kick (because they're so rare)

What do you guys think?

Edit:

Also, safety should be 3 points (because they're so rare), and passes defended should be 1 point.

nothing for forcing the fumble? I just looked and I have no idea why we made that 3 points (that's from 3 years ago) and I'm not saying it should be 3 but it should be worth something to make the hit.

[kuraitengai]

I think we should make the numbers be the same for D/ST and IDP (except for awarding D/ST tackle points). So I would say:

1 point per tackle (assisted or solo, same for each)
1 point per sack (this may have some contention, but is a sack other than a tackle for loss?)
2 points per RECOVERED fumble and INT
3 points per blocked kick (because they're so rare)

What do you guys think?

Edit:

Also, safety should be 3 points (because they're so rare), and passes defended should be 1 point.

i liked what stosh got on the yahoo standard scoring. im ok with not counting tackles for the D/ST cuz that would make the points jump too hight, unless it was something like 1 point for every 10 team tackles or something, but that would get too complicated.

1 point per sack is cool IF, i repeat IF, a sack counts as a tackle and a sack. then you are getting 1 point for a tackle and 1 point for a sack, so it still works out to 2 points for a sack. otherwise, a sack has no more value than a normal tackle.
so using osi's 6 sack day against the eagles last year. he had 6 tackles and 6 sacks. so assume that means every one of his tackles was a sack. so he would have 6 points from 6 tackles and 6 points for 6 sacks. so a total of 12 points.

[stoshuaj]

"anal dwelling butt monkey."

speaking of which, I'm toying w/the idea of running "Proctaglia Fugax" as my team name b/c I plan on being a pain in the ass to each and every one of you......lol

[kuraitengai]

I just looked, Chu was the last pick....that'd be pretty tight to not let him make a change if that's really what he wants to do. (and no, I don't want Henry.....)

if he is trying to change the pick he just made (travis henry) then go ahead and let him. i didnt know he was the last pick made and assumed it was a pick that has a few other picks made after him, then it wouldnt be fair to let him change and not the others. but if he changes his pick before the next pick (king i think) then let him. i got no problem with it.

[kuraitengai]

"anal dwelling butt monkey."

speaking of which, I'm toying w/the idea of running "Proctaglia Fugax" as my team name b/c I plan on being a pain in the ass to each and every one of you......lol

i loved that line from bruce almighty.....and i had been using it before the movie came out. so it was that much cooler.

edit: and need i refer to the movie van wilder on how to take care of an annoying rectal itch?

[Touchdown Redskins]

nothing for forcing the fumble?

Well, the reason I said no points for the forcing of the fumble is this:

We're not subtracting points from RBs or QBs for all fumbles, only the fumbles they lose. Thus, a forced fumble from a defender can result in either team getting the ball, whereas a recovered fumble has the result of the recoverer's team getting the ball. This way it's even with both offense and defense. Did that make any sense?

Edit: And good point about the sacks being 1 point but only if they're regarded as a tackle as well. I think that should be the way we should do it. Otherwise, we should upgrade a sack to two points.

[kuraitengai]

Well, the reason I said no points for the forcing of the fumble is this:

We're not subtracting points from RBs or QBs for all fumbles, only the fumbles they lose. Thus, a forced fumble from a defender can result in either team getting the ball, whereas a recovered fumble has the result of the recoverer's team getting the ball. This way it's even with both offense and defense. Did that make any sense?

Edit: And good point about the sacks being 1 point but only if they're regarded as a tackle as well. I think that should be the way we should do it. Otherwise, we should upgrade a sack to two points.

thats a good point. if we only count lost against the offense we should only count recovered for the D. that would be fair. i forgot we had that discussion a week or so ago.

[stoshuaj]

that's fine and damn near logical. yeah, definately only dinged for fumbles lost.

I don't know if we have a majority on this thing but Chuong's in the room now. May want to wait on the commish however.

[Touchdown Redskins]

Wait, so if Chuong9 gets to change his pick, would I get to change my pick, since I started off the 8th round?

Edit: I'm not saying this because I'm being a douche...but I was seriously considering taking a defensive player with that pick even without the new rules we are trying to implement. If I knew about this before, I probably would have taken a defensive player.

[Chuong9]

I think we'd need to tell everyone in the league before doing anything though, along with getting their confirmation. I'd like to change my pick, but don't mind if it's not possible.

[SkinsNut73]

I think we'd need to tell everyone in the league before doing anything though, along with getting their confirmation. I'd like to change my pick, but don't mind if it's not possible.

...too late...I already used permanent ink to scratch Henry off my draft list. Sorry.



...just kidding....fine by me as long as it's done before the next guy picks.