2012: Trade it all for the #1 pick(Probably Luck), even 2013 picks if needed?

[addicted]

addicted, I wouldn't be surprised if our rookie QB didn't play much his rookie year....but thats not what you said.


I was responding to the post below.

Your right I said 2 years
Ya got me man

[RichmondRedskin88]

I will remind folks

2004


Of all the picks of the 2004 Draft Let's look at them

#1 Eli Manning (1 SB a couple of play off wins)
#4 Phillip Rivers (Few Playoff wins, no Super Bowls)
#11 Big Ben (3 Super Bowls 2 Victories? Lots of Wins in the playoffs?)
#22 JP Losman (Where is that guy now?)


Big ben wasn't taken #1, but he's got to have one of the best records of any QB taken in the last 7 years in the playoffs.

One should point out Big Ben had a insane defense to back him up too.

[addicted]

I think the general point they're making is that if Shanahan believes a rookie QB is ready to play he will play him. That might not be week 1 but who knows; it depends on the rookie's progress/apparent readiness as well as how the incumbent is looking. I don't think he is the kind of coach who will sit a young QB JUST to sit him. If he were to get a kid like Luck I wouldn't be surprised if he was the week 1 starter.

I agree but I think there is a progression to a team and a #1 QB
For a team to land the top QB they have to have a bad team
Only the worst team drafts #1
If a team is the worst in the league unless it's a weird situation like the Colts this year who have a fanbase, the teams likely not got too much going for itself
That bad team needs a spark and something to get some butts in the seats and what do they have to lose starting that guy?
It gets the fans interested so he gets to go

A guy like Campbell or Rogers weren't picked #1 overall
Those guys got to sit for a while and learn
They are different, fans are more patient on average to let them mature
But with top signal callers they generally get thrown to the wolves for reasons not necessarily because they are the best chance to win

[Dannyc]

Week 13 is not about halfway through the season



Say what?
Jay Cutler the last QB taken by Coach Shannahan in the 1st round didn't start his first game until week 13 in his rookie year
That's the point Im making, if your so stuck on us needing to take a rookie QB and giving away all our picks to get him you have to know that he's not going to play much his first season


Anyway this team does have lots of holes to fill
We still need more corners
We still need more Defensive Linemen
We still need more Offensive Linemen
We still need a replacement for London Fletcher
If we don't re-sign Davis he will need replaced
Our current QB's are either on 1 year deals or will be in a contract season next year
And giving away tons of picks means we don't get to develop those positions

It means we don't get Ryan Kerrigan, Roy Helu, or Jarvis Jenkins, or Niles Paul, or Evan Royster, or Leonard Hankerson, or the rest of the rookies we got last year
And ultimately it means that since we are a team captained by men who are excellent at drafting and spoting skilled players
those wanting us to throw away the chance to improve the entire team would be taking one of best traits of this team and decide to go all in on one guy

If Vinny were still here playing games with Snyder I'd probably pull a Ditka and throw away all of our picks for the next Payton Manning
Because they showed like in 2008 that even with 10 draft picks they couldn't find any players
But I have seen and have faith in Coach Shannahans ability to draft and that's just too damn good to pull an All In move

What I'd like to see us do actually is to contact the Panthers and work out a deal with Jimmy Clausen for one of our received traded picks
JC is a talented QB, and he's never gonna get any playing time sitting behind Cam
Or I'd like to see us target Green Bay's backup Flynn and trade a middle round pick for him
Instead of just going all in for one guy in this years draft
Or even I'd like to see us draft multiple rookie QB's next year with the picks we have now and let them fight it out to be the starter
Anything but the stupid idea that we trade away all of our draft picks for one guy

Well, we know Helu and Kerrigan are solid players. The rest of the guys you named that we have drafted are total question marks still. We have no idea how Paul, Rosyter, Hankerson, etc. are going to do in the NFL. One thing I do agree with you is about contacting Carolina about Clausen. Personally, I would love for us to acquire Andrew Luck, I think it's worth trading a draft for him. I would trade all of the guys we drafted this season for Luck.

[36HAMMER]

in the end it really doesnt matter what we feel or think, if Mike feels that Luck is the one they want they will go after him.but i have alwaays said that our own history shows that a great line can carry a team to the superbowl better than a great qb with a so so oline.especially in this blitz happy league.i want a dominate center and left guard and i think that will settle this line down and improve our redzone woes. then we can get a qb that throws lazer beams and stuff.i am fed up with horse before the carriage.i would like some feed back on why the Skins passed on Johnathan Joeseph and G/ Davin Joeseph. both players are as good if not better than what we have.thanks people HTTR

[addicted]

This team needs a QB, and if Shanny and company can get an ellite QB they need to get him.

The only limits to improving our team are our imaginations and ability to scout

Before the Cowboys won the Superbowls in the 1990's they spent 2 first round picks in the same year on QB's
I wouldn't mind us spending two picks on two different QB's but I would mind us spending all of our picks on one guy

Before Green Bay won it's championship in the 1990's they spent a 2nd round pick on the little known backup QB in Atlanta
I wouldn't mind us spending a pick on someone's backup QB either

There is no reason to believe we have only one choice to find our guy

[SwampEm]

If we did it would rank right up there with this trade in 1989

Minnesota Vikings received

RB Herschel Walker
Dallas's 3rd round pick - 1990 (54) (Mike Jones)
San Diego's 5th round pick - 1990 (116) (Reggie Thornton)
Dallas's 10th round pick - 1990 (249) (Pat Newman)
Dallas's 3rd round pick - 1991 (68) (Jake Reed)

Dallas Cowboys received

LB Jesse Solomon
LB David Howard
CB Issiac Holt
RB Darrin Nelson (traded to San Diego after he refused to report to Dallas)
DE Alex Stewart
Minnesota's 1st round pick in 1990 (21) (traded this pick along with pick (81) for pick (17) from Pittsburgh to draft Emmitt Smith)
Minnesota's 2nd round pick in 1990 (47) (Alexander Wright)
Minnesota's 6th round pick in 1990 (158) (traded to New Orleans, who drafted James Williams)
Minnesota's 1st round pick in 1991 (conditional) - (12) (Alvin Harper)
Minnesota's 2nd round pick in 1991 (conditional) - (38) (Dixon Edwards)
Minnesota's 2nd round pick in 1992 (conditional) - (37) (Darren Woodson)
Minnesota's 3rd round pick in 1992 (conditional) - (71) (traded to New England, who drafted Kevin Turner)
Minnesota's 1st round pick in 1993 (conditional) - (13) (traded to Philadelphia Eagles, and then to the Houston Oilers, who drafted Brad Hopkins)

That one worked out really well for Minnesota...

[Dannyc]

If we did it would rank right up there with this trade in 1989

Minnesota Vikings received

RB Herschel Walker
Dallas's 3rd round pick - 1990 (54) (Mike Jones)
San Diego's 5th round pick - 1990 (116) (Reggie Thornton)
Dallas's 10th round pick - 1990 (249) (Pat Newman)
Dallas's 3rd round pick - 1991 (68) (Jake Reed)

Dallas Cowboys received

LB Jesse Solomon
LB David Howard
CB Issiac Holt
RB Darrin Nelson (traded to San Diego after he refused to report to Dallas)
DE Alex Stewart
Minnesota's 1st round pick in 1990 (21) (traded this pick along with pick (81) for pick (17) from Pittsburgh to draft Emmitt Smith)
Minnesota's 2nd round pick in 1990 (47) (Alexander Wright)
Minnesota's 6th round pick in 1990 (158) (traded to New Orleans, who drafted James Williams)
Minnesota's 1st round pick in 1991 (conditional) - (12) (Alvin Harper)
Minnesota's 2nd round pick in 1991 (conditional) - (38) (Dixon Edwards)
Minnesota's 2nd round pick in 1992 (conditional) - (37) (Darren Woodson)
Minnesota's 3rd round pick in 1992 (conditional) - (71) (traded to New England, who drafted Kevin Turner)
Minnesota's 1st round pick in 1993 (conditional) - (13) (traded to Philadelphia Eagles, and then to the Houston Oilers, who drafted Brad Hopkins)

That one worked out really well for Minnesota...

A franchise RB is not the same as a franchise QB.

[addicted]

Well, we know Helu and Kerrigan are solid players. The rest of the guys you named that we have drafted are total question marks still. We have no idea how Paul, Rosyter, Hankerson, etc. are going to do in the NFL.

I saw in preseason that those guys have some work to do but will become playmakers some day in the league
It may not be week one but like the Ravens wideout, it will happen eventually
But since you only know about Helu and Kerrigan lets not forget the second to last pick in the draft Chris Neild
Chris Neild in his first three games has 2 sacks and has been very good in his limited time
The point I'm making is that when you have a staff who can spot talent and manuver a draft like we just did
The idea that you go all in and draft one single player is like shooting ourselves in the foot

[Dannyc]

I saw in preseason that those guys have some work to do but will become playmakers some day in the league
It may not be week one but like the Ravens wideout, it will happen eventually
But since you only know about Helu and Kerrigan lets not forget the second to last pick in the draft Chris Neild
Chris Neild in his first three games has 2 sacks and has been very good in his limited time
The point I'm making is that when you have a staff who can spot talent and manuver a draft like we just did
The idea that you go all in and draft one single player is like shooting ourselves in the foot

What if your staff believes Luck is the next Peyton Manning? Would it not be worth it then?

[Symbol]

Why do I keep coming to the Stadium? Every time there's a bad game it's the end of the world, let's trade our next 20 years picks for this player or that player. Let's get rid of this player because he's a joke. The moment we win these same people are like, this guy that I just said was the worst player in the world, well now he's a GOD.

[Riggo#44]

Unless Seattle takes Andrew Luck, Pete Carroll will not pass on Matt Barkley. I know he hasn't taken a ton of trojans in the 2 drafts he has done (if any) but Barkley unlike a Taylor Mays, does have a skill set that translates to the NFL, he's familiar with him, having recruited him and coached him (remeber he started him as a freshman) and was truly enamored with him while he was still coaching USC.

To get him, you would have to either hope Seattle gets the #1 pick, or you will have to leap frog them to get Barkley. However, if Seattle gets Luck, Barkley could fall till after Landry Jones.

Assuming Pete Carroll is there next year. Seattle is really bad this year. Really bad. They still finished under .500 last year too (including the fluke win over the Saints in the playoffs). They could very well be #1 overall -- and if they're top 5, I see them taking Jones over Barkley.

[BRAVEONAWARPATH]

Your right I said 2 years
Ya got me man

[Rypien1191]

Rex is not going to win us a Super Bowl.

But he is good enough where we can build a team around the QB and progressively get better as a team, and he won't set us backwards.

[dallasfan]

Assuming Pete Carroll is there next year. Seattle is really bad this year. Really bad. They still finished under .500 last year too (including the fluke win over the Saints in the playoffs). They could very well be #1 overall -- and if they're top 5, I see them taking Jones over Barkley.

I doubt he's not in Seattle next year. They definately over achieved last year (how can I say that about a 7-9 team?!) and picking 26th in each round hurt. I see him getting several more seasons before the plug is pulled, after all you don't pay a guy almost 7 million over 5 years, give him control over football operations and fire him after 2 years.

I would be shocked if he took Jones over Barkley. I think Jones is the better prospect, atleast for now, but he just couldn't stop raving about how great Barkley was during that whole season. If Jones is far and away the better prospect, then he may take him, but I think Jones is gonna edge Barkley out just by a bit when the draft process is over.