2012 Fantasy Football Thread

[Bliz]

Starters are pretty well set, but having a tough time deciding on my flex in a 0.5 PPR

Jordy Nelson v SF, or
Antonio Brown @ Den


Also thinking about dropping Tamme for Greg Olson.

[elkabong82]

I'd lean toward Brown because it's ppr and he'll likely have more receptions. Both defenses are good, but SF is the top D starting out the season. Either player is a good start though.

[MattFancy]

Starters are pretty well set, but having a tough time deciding on my flex in a 0.5 PPR

Jordy Nelson v SF, or
Antonio Brown @ Den


Also thinking about dropping Tamme for Greg Olson.

Maybe lean towards Nelson? Not sure you can really go wrong with either one.

Would hold off on dropping Tamme for Olsen. Let's see how Tamme plays with Manning first.

[MikeSellers45]

In one of my leagues I have Romo as my starting QB with Dalton as my backup. Flacco is available and I was wondering if I should dump Dalton for him

[MattFancy]

In one of my leagues I have Romo as my starting QB with Dalton as my backup. Flacco is available and I was wondering if I should dump Dalton for him

Too early to make a move for that. Flacco could be decent, but with Romo, you really aren't going to bench him much, so Dalton should be fine. But if you really want Flacco, then go for it.

[MikeSellers45]

Too early to make a move for that. Flacco could be decent, but with Romo, you really aren't going to bench him much, so Dalton should be fine. But if you really want Flacco, then go for it.

The only time I plan on using my backup is for the bye week, so I will just stick with Dalton.

[bushwack]

In one of my leagues I have Romo as my starting QB with Dalton as my backup. Flacco is available and I was wondering if I should dump Dalton for him

Yes, I would do that ASAP. At worst you have a solid back up, who you could trade later in the season, or if Romo was to get hurt you have a quality guy in Flacco instead of not much in Dalton.

[MattFancy]

Yes, I would do that ASAP. At worst you have a solid back up, who you could trade later in the season, or if Romo was to get hurt you have a quality guy in Flacco instead of not much in Dalton.

But is there really that much of a difference between Flacco and Dalton?

[bushwack]

But is there really that much of a difference between Flacco and Dalton?

IMO yes, a big difference. Flacco has a much better arm and better weapons around him in Rice, Smith, & Boldin. Also, Flacco is in a contract year.

[MattFancy]

IMO yes, a big difference. Flacco has a much better arm and better weapons around him in Rice, Smith, & Boldin. Also, Flacco is in a contract year.

I don't think its that big of difference and its not like AJ Green, Gresham, and BJGE are chopped liver. Flacco very well could be better, but we're talking about QB2s here at best. You're not gonna bench Romo for Flacco except for a bye week. Maybe if Flacco has a can't miss match up, but I don't really see one.

[NLC1054]

Alright, I need some advice;

Would of you trade Ryan Mathews straight up for Matt Ryan? I feel like Matty Ice is going to break out and have a really good year, but I don't want trading Ryan to come back and bite me in the ass.

My two quarterbacks are Big Ben and Flacco and I don't know if that's good enough...

[mojo]

Toby Gerhart vs Jags
or
Justin Blackmon vs Vikings

I don't think AP will get many carries if he plays at all this week so I'm leaning Gerhart but I have a feeling Blackmon could have a big game.

[MattFancy]

Alright, I need some advice;

Would of you trade Ryan Mathews straight up for Matt Ryan? I feel like Matty Ice is going to break out and have a really good year, but I don't want trading Ryan to come back and bite me in the ass.

My two quarterbacks are Big Ben and Flacco and I don't know if that's good enough...

Who are your other RBs? I really like Matt Ryan too, but if you are weak at RB I wouldn't do it.

[Fan since a Fetus]

Also thinking about dropping Tamme for Greg Olson.

I am not as high as other on Tamme because he will be splitting catches with Dreesen. On top of that, Broncos depth chart has Dreesen as the starter. People are putting too much stock in the Manning/Tamme combo. If Dreesen or Tamme get hurt, then the other one will be a factor.

I would have already picked up Olson. Olson and Shockey combined for 80+ catches last year. Olson does not have Shockey there anymore. Chud also said that Olson has the talent to be an elite TE.

[MikeSellers45]

If you had the option between Jonathan Stewart and Mike Robert, who would you pick?