Finished looking at two other safeties last night:
T.J Mcdonald- USC FS ( Cal, Arizona, Stanford)
- Big guy with slightly below avg. speed
- Good tackler overall: Solid angles and technique
- Average reaction time/ Instincts
- Coverage is solid, can be lined up on a slower WR/TE if need be
- Doesn’t make plays when playing deep
- Fundamentally Sound player, rarely out of position
McDonald doesn’t have the quick reflexes/instincts and speed needed to be a great FS. He is best suited at SS where he can be used in a variety of ways.
Bicarri Rambo- Georgia FS (Alabama, Auburn, Georgia Tech)
- Above Avg. Speed
- Can’t shed blockers
- Tackling- Takes good angles and is a good tackler overall. Early in the year he tried a few tackles by standing up which gives him leverage to strip the ball but he would do it one on one which is a disaster waiting to happen. In his final games he showed much improved technique with only a few missteps.
- Reacts quickly to the ball
- Centerfielder Type- Has a good eye for the ball and hands to go along with it.
Currently my favorite FS over Reid, McDonald, and Thomas.
I like the idea the only issue is the lack of film on youtube. Just from me searching there might be 3-4 games per player max and there is not enough to judge properly on a few things. I might be just searching for the wrong thing though. That list is probably overkill for this audience, it needs to be condensed somewhat. For example, close speed, catch up speed and burst are so similar that they could probably go together . Also read and instincts are difficult to tell apart so they that could be together too.
I would be interested in seeing what happens w/ Marcus Lattimore if he falls in the draft.
Like what I see from JJ Wilcox today
Just living the dream of a college kid wanting to be something
NFLDraftMonsters.com--- check it
@JTPartlow21
I agree there is limited film on youtube. But, I wouldn't attempt to breakdown more then 2 games each. We could breakdown 1 of the same game, then breakdown a different game a piece if there was a total of 3 cut-ups etc...(I'll PM)
I agree that list is a bit much. I could do away with a large portion on the list for our purposes starting with more subjective measures.
Maybe we could reach a consensus on the most important traits then give each prospect a grade in that given category between say 1-5 for example:
------------------SPEED--------TCKLG----------FS snaps
Reid---------------4-----------------5---------------------5
Thomas----------3-----------------4---------------------4
McDonald-------4-----------------5----------------------3
One of the main areas I would look for are the play stats: tackles attempted/tackles made; plays made in coverage etc, snaps played in the box, snaps played at centerfield, snaps played at slot DB etc.
Does this makes senses?
I see we are talking about Eric Reed from LSU. Right now Kiper does have him in the 1st round. I've been watching Reed since last year, and I actually like what he has to offer. Also the FS from Texas Vacarro is ranked as the #1 safety on Kiper's big board, where as Reed is ranked #4. I'll post the top 5 safties on his board:
Kenny Vaccaro Texas 6-1 218
Matt Elam* Florida 5-10 206
Tony Jefferson* Oklahoma 5-10 199
Eric Reid* LSU 6-2 208
Phillip Thomas Fresno St. 6-1 215
The asterisk's means they are underclass men. Those are his top 5. I guess McDonald from USC in his opinion had a so-so year this season.
Am I crazy, or does TJ McDonald remind anyone a little of what we saw from Tanard Jackson in the preseason? (minus the pot)
---------- Post added January-23rd-2013 at 04:49 PM ----------
McDonald is used heavily as a blitzer, so he'll have fewer snap stats in the other spots. Despite being a safety, I feel like he's actually one of the better pass rushers on USC. With his ability to side-step a RB or quickly squirt through a hole between o-lineman. So while it would detract him in the FS snap totals, he's still exhibiting a useful skill.
I feel like Haslett would LOVE having McDonald.
Last edited by Alcoholic Zebra; January-23rd-2013 at 03:49 PM.
HTTR
We will probably need two games at least to get enough material on players like Vaccaro who could spend the majority of one game playing CB. We should probably pick the games against the toughest competition if we have the option. A numerical grade sounds good. Regarding the stats on tackles is that something we have to calculate or is there already a resource for this?
Interesting to note that we've spoken to a good amount of TE's this week
Just living the dream of a college kid wanting to be something
NFLDraftMonsters.com--- check it
@JTPartlow21
http://bleacherreport.com/tb/d9tY5?u...ngton-redskins
Tyrann Mathieu reportedly spoke with the Redskins, Jets at the Senior Bowl
According to Ben Volin of the Palm Beach Post, former LSU cornerback and kick returner Tyrann Mathieu was in attendance even though he wasn’t invited to take part.
Mathieu spoke with some media members and even some teams, such as the Redskins and Jets.
Mathieu knows he’s going to have to do everything he can to improve his draft stock.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)