Kickers are like long snappers. If you're talking about them, they're probably screwing up.
Get Cundiff outta here now, get Gano back, at least he's got some upside, and if our SpTeam had stepped up last year and managed to prevent the rush getting to him, we wouldn't even be having this discussion. Much rather have him back than some veteran kicker no-one else wants. At Least with Gano, we know what we're getting, and he has some years left so if he did improve (which in fairness to the guy, he did seem to be), we could keep him around and not have to burn a draft pick to get another one. Get a veteran and they're retiring in a couple of years, their skills are already declining and we definitely have to burn a draft pick or keep up the veteran cast-off Kicker carousel.