Are we still really talking about this?
Dude scored a TD. We won the game. Who cares?
Are we still really talking about this?
Dude scored a TD. We won the game. Who cares?
This forum requires that you wait 60 seconds between searches. Please try again in 62 seconds.
This forum requires that you wait 60 seconds between sending private messages. Please try again in 127 seconds.
If they reviewed DeSean Jackson's a couple years ago and Brandon Banks' last year in the preseason but not Morris', then I'm not worried
"Watching RG3 today is like watching Jordan vs. the Blazers years ago. Waiting for him to shrug his shoulders as he runs by cameras." - John Keim, November 22, 2012. Thanksgiving at Dallas
It's tough to see from the low resolutions highlights I keep finding, but it looks like it was actually pretty close. I tried to pause the youtube video at the point he released the ball, but it's just a rough guess without an HD video.
EDIT: It definitely looks like a TD, but I can see why people are saying it's unnecessarily close.
![]()
Last edited by HBnotBlades; October-2nd-2012 at 01:28 PM.
The ref is right there on the goal line??? If it wasn't close enough for him to say something, then I am cool with it.
Gone, but not forgotten... RIP RP
We are going overboard on the handwringing in this thread. Close only counts in horse shoes and hand grenades.
When the play happened on Sun, I don't recall thinking that he dropped the ball prior to crossing the goal line....didn't even think it was close. And....replays concentrated on the blocking and the run vice what happened at the goal line. On the other hand I recall watching Jackson drop the ball prior to crossing the goal line a couple of seasons ago.....and it did appear that he dropped the ball early.
The advice is sound, though, about making sure not to drop the ball prior to crossing the goal line.....maybe the coaches will put a reminder in his ear this week so something dumb doesn't happen in the future.
This forum requires that you wait 60 seconds between searches. Please try again in 62 seconds.
This forum requires that you wait 60 seconds between sending private messages. Please try again in 127 seconds.
The ball was CLEARLY a yard deep in the end zone. This hand wringing has to stop. The officials have reviewed and overturned calls like this regularly. If they didn't pause to review it, it was obviously not even close. If there is even a question, they review it.
Last edited by Popeman38; October-2nd-2012 at 05:39 PM.
![]()
Sig courtesy of Sticksboi05
You know, I saw that on the replay after he scored, and was so sure that he fumbled. Can't really tell from there, but it seemed like it would've been worthy of a review from the refs. I was surprised that no one mentioned it after the commercial break.
Last edited by Mr. Sinister; October-2nd-2012 at 05:46 PM.
The point is he shouldn't be doing it at all. He really cant take a few more steps into the endzone before throwing the ball away? Seriously, its too close for comfort I dont care if the ref called it or had reason to question it or not. Whats the big deal, it is a chance for coach to correct him on something and remove the CHANCE that maybe he lets go a little early one game. What is the harm in that?
He was in the endzone CLEARLY. This thread should be awarded "Dumbest thread on ES"
Last edited by skinsfan07; October-2nd-2012 at 05:50 PM.
I would say the ball was not clearly in the endzone, if fans were concerned. Slow motion replay, sure maybe it was clear.
Players shouldn't cut it that close, there should be no doubt among fans especially on uncontested touchdown runs.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)