Per Gregg Rosenthal: Rookie QB Week 4 ranks: Tannehill or RG3?

[Koolblue13]

What a great draft class.

[Zazzaro703]

Funny thing is, if anyone watched the NFL network Monday night pregame show, both Billick and D Green chose first quarter rookies of the year, and NEITHER chose RG3. Green chose Claiborne, and Billick chose Kalil. I could not believe my eyes and ears, but I guess RG3 is making this look so damn easy that people have forgotten he's a rookie!

Wow I missed that. I mean the only knock on him I can think of is he lost two games, but put us in position both games not his fault twice people took 15 yard penalties after the play.

[Warhead36]

RG3 is easily the ROY so far. Guys trying to name others are just trying too hard to sound smart.

[Rocky52Mc]

Honestly, I don't listen to anything Rosenthal says. He says **** to attract attention, it comes off as pathetic.

His NFL.com bio "Gregg Rosenthal writes for and manages Around the League for NFL.com, providing non-stop analysis and opinions on all things football. He spent nine years covering the NFL for NBC Sports, Rotoworld.com, and ProFootballTalk.com. He is not 15 years old despite his appearance."

His work at roto and PFT is a combination of negative and sarcastic remarks geared towards pissing off 4 fan bases, and making the other 28 look away.

Tannehill more flashy than RG3? I guess the B.Banks pass to him wasn't sexy, maybe jumping down a cliff into the endzone several times isn't sexy, flicking accurate darts in clutch time isn't sexy, I guess you have to lose to be sexy in this league.

Well if RG3 gives a ****, he should act more like this to gain Gregg's sparkling eye.

[Ghost of Nibbs McPimpin]

I may be the only one, but I really don't find Tannehill's wife that great looking either.

Oh boy, you stepped in it. They're going to be all over you now. How can you turn down Elway's mouth with Chris Webber's hands and Marty Feldman's eyes!!?!?! But it's got blonde hair and it's thinner than a well-disguised(?) tranny!

[Enter Apotheosis]

I may be the only one, but I really don't find Tannehill's wife that great looking either.

Both Griffin's fiancee and Tannehill's wife fall in to the territory that the vast majority of all people fall into where they're average-ish genetically but have the ability to look pretty damn attractive with a little effort or not-so-appealing on a bad day or in an off-photo. That said, I don't get why Lauren gets as much admiration from some as she does. She's got a really run of the mill lanky look about her and a face that is just okay. She sure as hell isn't a supermodel.

[Mr. Sinister]

Oh boy, you stepped in it. They're going to be all over you now. How can you turn down Elway's mouth with Chris Webber's hands and Marty Feldman's eyes!!?!?! But it's got blonde hair and it's thinner than a well-disguised(?) tranny!

And Smeagol's legs...

[darrelgreenie]

I actually watched the Dolphins vs Cardinals game and its the best passing performance by a rookie QB that I've seen this season (and I've watched most of them).

[Gibbs Hog Heaven]

I may be the only one, but I really don't find Tannehill's wife that great looking either.

I need a side by side comparison before I can score.

Call it, uhmmm, Redskin homework.

Hail.

[thesubmittedone]

Any time a rookie QB leads his team on a game winning drive nothing else matters. It's that simple. All Tannehill did was throw an INT in over time that ended up costing the dolphins a win. RG3, on the other hand, almost single handedly won the game for us on that final drive. That's it. How this is even debatable is ridiculous.

[Skins4Life6388]

I may be the only one, but I really don't find Tannehill's wife that great looking either.

Seconded. Don't mistake me and think I'm saying shes ugly. But a lot of my leg humper buddies kept talking about how she was so hot.

[darrelgreenie]

I'm curious how many people that are commenting on Tannehill's Week 4 performance actually watched the game vs just reading a box score?

[Jumbo]

Let's stick with football as the topic. That gets dumb enough, often enough.

[TheItalianStallion]

Can we please stop discussing his wife whenever a discussion of Tannehill comes up? It's getting old.

[rskin72]

Well, I did not see the Dolfinks game....so cannot comment on Tannehill's performance. I would think that.....overall....the most consistent rookie performances at QB thusfar have been RGIII and Luck. At least....from this totally UNBIASED observer....should be a no brainer for RGIII