Ketchup on a cheesesteak. Yes or No?

[zoony]

Karate would be Japanese.

[Koolblue13]

Karate would be Japanese.

I'll let this joke go before I put my foot in my mouth instead of a cheesesteak.

[zskins]

Wtf is wrong with you people? You don't put catsup on ribeye. Period. There is no discussion here

It depends. If it is made really juicy then no. If not then I will dip into my ketchup but not put it on the cheesesteak. You can substitute that with barbecue sauce as well. I try different things all of the time so one must has to see what one's taste bud say.

[Bang]

I like a sparse steak.
Light mayo.. like barely any.. provolone cheese is a must
Grilled onions, grilled mushrooms.

mmm

~Bang

[skinsfan07]

My roommate and I have a disagreement. Is it blasphemous to put ketchup on a cheesesteak?

Help us come to a conclusion ES!

Yes it is. Ketchup doesn't deserve to be anywhere near an old fashioned Philly.

[Bang]

I like a sparse steak.
Light mayo.. like barely any.. provolone cheese is a must
Grilled onions, grilled mushrooms.

mmm

~Bang

[Koolblue13]

I like a sparse steak.
Light mayo.. like barely any.. provolone cheese is a must
Grilled onions, grilled mushrooms.

mmm

~Bang

No matter how many times you repeat this, nobody is making you a cheesesteak

[Taylor703]

is it that serious? lol

Hell yeah I put ketchup on it. I put ketchup on everything

My feelings exactly. I absolutely love ketchup.

[Mr. Sinister]

Ketchup is the Devil.

[MLSKINS]

On a steak and cheese from the carry out, Mayo, Lettuce, and Tomatoes....

On a Philly Cheese Steak, nothing.

[matty dread]

Ketchup belongs on fries only. Even then I use it sparingly.

[da#1skinsfan]

On a steak and cheese from the carry out, Mayo, Lettuce, and Tomatoes....

On a Philly Cheese Steak, nothing.

Bingo.

A true cheesesteak is all about 3 things - cheese, steak, bread. Onions/peppers/shrooms are acceptable per your interests, but when you start throwing condiments and lettuce/tomato on there, you are no longer eating a cheesesteak, it's now a hoagie.

In my opinion, the only cheesesteak that requires ketchup is a DRY cheesesteak (JIM'S!!!!)

[Koolblue13]

I'm from the north and couldn't give a **** if it's gas or charcoal. Actually, I prefer gas 10 times to 1.

Charcoal?!? Where am I? Uganda? Grow up, buy a tank or cut some wood.

[Birdlives]

I'm from the north and couldn't give a **** if it's gas or charcoal. Actually, I prefer gas 10 times to 1.

Charcoal?!? Where am I? Uganda? Grow up, buy a tank or cut some wood.

Do you put ketchup on your charcoal?


In all seriousness, now I'm goning to have to get one.

Blows my diet, but all this talk is driving me crazy.

[RabidFan]

Honestly i first read the question as "ketchup on a cheesecake" to which i thought you needed the white coats to come get you right away.

As for the cheesesteak? The wife and i don't put it on it but put some on the plate beside it for dipping.