I'm most concerned with his fear factor..He looks totally afraid out there and will not go over the middle and short hands a lot of stuff.
I'm most concerned with his fear factor..He looks totally afraid out there and will not go over the middle and short hands a lot of stuff.
do you call roddy white a bust? how about brandon marshall? how about dwayne bowe or desean jackson? each one of them has over 25 drops the past 3 seasons.... it happens, everyone drops the ball from time to time, you can be patient til hes cut, and ill be patient til i can say told ya so and shut you up
You know, there has been so much talk on the boards about not having a legit QB since, well, at least Rypien, that people forget that our WR crew has been basically just as crap for 20 years as well. There have been a few high points, like Moss in 2005, and Westbrook and AC had a good year or two. But in general, the WR play has been abysmal.
Toss in failures like Thomas and Kelly, and now you get a pretty anxious fan base.
And then toss in that it looks like we've FINALLY got a QB, a RB, and the OL is better than expected, and there is little patience for WR growth.
And finally, fans want the team to win, patience or not, primarily because of how well RGIII is playing. And up to this point, the WRs have been doing their job. They all had a bad game on Sunday.
The real problem isn't drops, it's the defense couldn't stop the Langley HS offense at the moment.
Actually, Hank hasn't had that many huge drops. The one on Sunday actually turned out to be nothing, because they scored a TD on a drive later.
If you want to find the receiver who had had the most crushing drops over the past 7 years, he wears #89. He has consistently dropped or fumbled at the absolute worst times in games. He also makes up for it with some great catches. But he's been the culprit more times than not on just awful drops. And he had 2 more this past weekend. And his fumble ended the Giants game.
How about he gets a full 16 games with a real QB to figure out how good he can be? Also, something to remember, he missed the ENTIRE off season with his hip issue. He didn't start practicing until training camp. And last year, there wasn't an off season.
I think a full off season with RGIII and the other WRs will do miracles for him.
Agree here. One of my biggest pet peeves in all of football is dropped passes. If it hits you in the hands, catch the damn ball. Everything I've said above is more about his ability to get open, make plays, etc. But he's GOT to catch the ball.
I think that he's going to probably catch so many balls this off season his hands will be raw. That's the benefit of the OTAs and Mini-Camps, none of which he's ever been able to attend. He should be able to work 1-1 with a bunch of coaches, and they should be able to get this fixed.
Aldrick isn't as quick as Moss. Having somebody who can back up Garcon is critical. The problem is that they need somebody to stretch the field. Robinson has that ability. He's just got to mature and use it.
Moss doesn't stink, he's been the best WR they've had for almost a decade. He still is able to use his quickness to get open. The biggest issue with Moss is his absolutely untimely drops and fumbles. It means that he's not elite, but he's far from sucking. And to say that a WR picked in the 3rd round, who didn't have the benefit of an off season last year or this year due to lockout and injury, is a bit pre-mature.
There appears to be a light at the end of the tunnel. I just hope it's not a train.
Those receivers you mention have all been very productive. Hank hasn't. You are asking me to compare apples to oranges.
If I'm wrong, I'll be more than happy to admit it. And you can say 'I told you so' when that happens. But, for right now, you are just another poster making another dumb argument.
---------- Post added October-30th-2012 at 02:53 PM ----------
We disagree on level of incompetence required to label it "suckitude." We also disagree on how much time it takes to judge WR talent. I judged Hank to be lacking in natural talent in August of last year. He hasn't shown anything since to cause me to change my mind. You don't learn to acquire natural talent.
Mike Wise nick name for Briscoe ...Is Devin Crisco buahahah!!!
All those other receivers have also played a full season.
Roddy White's first two seasons are relatively close to Hank's: 59 Receptions, 952 yards, 3 TDs.
Marshall's first season was very similar: 20 receptions, 309 yards, 2 TDs
Sometimes it takes time for receivers to come into their own. Just because you judged him to be lacking doesn't mean he is. I choose to go by his entire career, college included, and the natural talent is there. You don't go setting records at Miami and not have natural talent.
OLB Coach for the 3x State Champs: 2001, 2002, 2008 Atlantic Shores Seahawks2012 Final Record: 2-9
He's maybe worthy of a roster spot until he develops, but if he's gonna be our starter, then we're pretty deficient relative to the competition.
But if Garcon is out there at 100%, and Morgan and Moss are out there, maybe Hank isn't and his deficiencies aren't exposed as much. He's probably playing when he shouldn't be.
And on a side note, I'm still waiting on that jump ball to Hank or Brisco. We've got two relatively tall receivers whose height we don't exploit.
Last edited by justice98; October-30th-2012 at 02:18 PM.
One guy I'd like to see (who does seem to be smooth and have great ball skills) is Aldrick Robinson. The plays he makes do seem more effortless than Hankerson's at this time. I certainly understand the eyeball test point that Oldfan is making but am holding out hope that Hankerson develops once he gets more comfortable.
"Washington strolled to the NFC championship, outscoring their two playoff opponents by a combined total of 48 points. Their domination was more than impressive, it was historic. The 1991 Redskins boasted the largest average margin of victory among all Super Bowl champions."
--- America's Game
I didn't get to see Roddy White much in his rookie year. I saw Brandon Marshall in his rookie year and, despite his drops, my reaction was : "How in the the hell did that guy drop to the fourth round!?" He couldn't be covered one on one.
I'm talking about pro level natural talent. College level is another matter.
Last edited by Oldfan; October-30th-2012 at 02:37 PM.
OLB Coach for the 3x State Champs: 2001, 2002, 2008 Atlantic Shores Seahawks2012 Final Record: 2-9
Being a Redskins fan prepares you for life.
Vinny Cerrato believes he gave Jim Zorn a roster that can make the playoffs. A playoff kicker doesn't miss that kick. A playoff safety doesn't bite multiple times by a double move in the same game.Originally Posted by suze109
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)