What's the best way to make a PB&J sandwich?

[Taylor703]

For some reason I like PB&J on potato bread. I love Wegmans Cherry jelly and after making fun of my girlfriend for buying this peanut butter I ended up needing to use it one day when we ran out of Jif, felt like a fool cause the stuff tastes amazing lol.

http://www.vitacost.com/peanut-butter-co-white-chocolate-wonderful-16-oz?csrc=GPF-PA-851087000052&ci_sku=851087000052&ci_gpa=pla&ci_kw= {keyword}&gclid=CMma6JX-v7MCFdKd4AodC3AAkw

[Spaceman Spiff]

So... how did you make it Spiff ?

Jiff, grape jelly, sometimes strawberry. Spread the peanut butter on one side first, fairly thick. Jelly on top of that. No cut.

[China]

I gotta agree on the lightly toasted. Also, no love for crushed up chips on it too?

Agree, not just spreading the PB on toast, but making the whole sandwich and sticking it in the toaster oven.

[Sticksboi05]

Went out to the store today while at work and brought back makings for PB&J and I asked my buddy if he wanted me to make him one, too.

He said yes, then proceeded to bust my balls for making it wrong. I left the crust on and didn't cut it in half. Whatever.

So that made me think...what's the most popular way to make a PB&J sandwich?

It's a multiple choice poll.

No crust, what is he watching Sesame Street?

[I_Bleed_B&G]

Only children don't eat crust.

Heisenberg would like a word with you

[Sticksboi05]

You should be banned, like, now. Mods? Some action here? This is serious ****.

Nothing, nothing is worse than creamy peanut butter. It's peanut butter with the best part taken out. It should be outlawed. I'm offended by it's existence.


Oops. I was so blinded with rage I forgot to answer the OP.

Peter Pan Honey Roast Crunchy.
Any non-grape jelly is acceptable.
The crust stays on.
WHEAT bread.
Not cut.

None of this is debatable.

George Washington Carver intended on a smooth peanut butter. Not some jagged shell filled tomfoolery.

[pjfootballer]

Heisenberg would like a word with you

http://markp427.files.wordpress.com/...pg?w=545&h=286

Tell him to "bring it" and his crust too!

[MattFancy]

This thread inspired me to go home and eat a PB&J for lunch. Thank you OP!

[DM72]

Anyone here ever try the Elvis peanut butter and banana sandwich? Very good.

[pjfootballer]

Yes, I lived in Memphis from 1986-1994. It IS good.

[#98QBKiller]

Honestly, I don't know anyone who prefers chunky.

*raises hand*

[RonArtest15]

I love eating clean and organic...however I will NEVER compromise using Jif when making a PB&J. FWIW, PB&J might be the best sandwich ever. Close second is grilled cheese, but that thread can be for another day.

If you're going to make one, make it right.

Pepperidge Farms Oatmeal Bread
Jif
Strawberry Jelly

*you're going to need a 2/1 ratio of PB to Jelly.

[Houston2Taylor2Landry]

Toasted White Bread

Apply Chunky Peanut Butter to bread directly out of the toaster.. Both Sides.

Apply Strawberry Jelly to BOTH sides.

Big Ol Glass of Milk.

[MLSKINS]

Anyone here ever try the Elvis peanut butter and banana sandwich? Very good.

I had the peanut butter and banana on graham crackers.

[rictus58]

Anyone here ever try the Elvis peanut butter and banana sandwich? Very good.

I got it when i visited graceland a few years ago. It was gone in 2 minutes.