If you look at this year alone, and don't consider previous seasons...Is RG3 an "elite" qb right now?
RG3 is currently 3rd in QB rating, snuggled in between Rodgers, P. Manning, Tom Brady and Big Ben. And all of those guys around him are considered "elite."
5th in completion percentage
2nd in yards per pass
2nd best TD/INT ratio in the NFL, over 4:1, amazing.
tied for fewest turnovers in the NFL among active QBs with Tom Brady
Broke the all-time NFL rookie QB rushing record