The Almighty Quarterback Bandwagon Runs Out of Control

[Oldfan]

Fair Enough.

RG3 probably comes in around 15% given the % of rushes he has in this scheme so far.

Spread the other 85% across the rest of the sample and he calculates at being at least 5 times more important than anyone else within that 100%.

That's about right.

---------- Post added November-27th-2012 at 04:55 PM ----------

Although it is not a perfect indicator of intelligence, some of these factors could be considered when making a 'grade'. These are fairly easy to see and focus on the decision making of a QB. 1) If a QB has a history of making mental errors (i.e. throwing into triple coverage, missing open receivers, bad penalties) 2) if they have poor game management (i.e. delay of game penalties, poor clock management) 3) If they effectively audible into productive plays, Im sure there are more as well but these can be seen and graded as effectively as judging mechanics.

Sorry, my friend. I read posters claiming to be able to grade those things and it usually ends up being a biased view. Their favorite QBs get praised for being great at those things and they slam QBs they don't like.

Only someone like the OC, who knows what the QB's assignment was, and who to blame, can do the job fairly.