Poll: Is there ANY player in the NFL you would trade RG3 straight up for?

[FSUSkins24]

Andrew Luck

[Shabby]

uhhhhh nope, no way, cant do it

[mistertim]

OK then Thank God your a fan, SMH...Luck equal to RGIII hahaha they are two different QBs with two different styles of play. Let me guess, you were one of those Phans (see I didn't give you the true spelling of Fan) that probably wanted Luck..

Why is it necessary to insult someone by questioning their fanhood if they have a different opinion than you? Its not like he said RG3 sucks and Luck is better or something. Also, thank you for adding the section in parentheses. That "Phans" jab was so subtle that I never would have caught it otherwise.


As far as the OP, I don't think I would trade him for anyone 1 for 1. There are some players who are more valuable than him right now but that may not last very long and he will be here for 10-15 years. Another thing is that nobody even knows what in the world his ceiling will be and that is pretty scary considering how well he is doing as a 22 year old rookie.

[nuposse87]

with our current roster...no.

[terrifNick21]

[Dan T.]

So....you would possibly trade 4 interceptions for 16? That aside what is there that makes you believe that Luck would be the better long term prospect other than the "long line of experts" hanging off of Luck's Johnson? I am not being argumentative, I would still really love to hear an intelligent argument from somebody, heck anybody, as to what makes Luck's long term prospects greater than RGIII's.

Andrew Luck is going to be a premier quarterback for many years. I guarantee you his TD/interception rate will improve in coming years. His college TD/INT numbers were 13/4, 32/8, and 37/10. He's the complete package. If a personnel guy, looking long term, is concerned about Griffin's durability issues given his size and the offense he's asked to run, then a Griffin for Luck trade would make sense.

[clskinsfan]

OK then Thank God your a fan, SMH...Luck equal to RGIII hahaha they are two different QBs with two different styles of play. Let me guess, you were one of those Phans (see I didn't give you the true spelling of Fan) that probably wanted Luck..

Yes I did prefer Luck. And how does that make me a questionable fan? Luck had the better college career. And if you think he is not as talented as RG3 then you my friend are a blind homer. My family has had season tickets since 1969. How long have you had yours?

[DiscoBob]

I may reluctantly trade him for Luck and Calvin Johnson....

It'd take 3 players - Luck, Johnson, and JJ Watt to make me do it happily

[skinsmarydu]

No, no, no. Luck didn't even graduate till after Robert. That alone says, "I wanna play, and I wanna win." Fundamentals. I wanna be there first. That's ambition. No way, have been over the moon since we traded up. Every week my hubby gets to see what I've been singing about. He's becoming a believer. Now, if the Falcons would get outta the way...lol
Hail!

[CTskins]

Not a chance...

Untapped marketing potential
Unrivaled excitement
Unbelieveable charisma

Oh yeah, the kid plays the game pretty well too.

[RSimports]

Negative. He brings way to much to the table. Most players are lucky to the skill set he has let alone the intangibles.

[darrelgreenie]

No caveats, simple question.

As of right now is there any other player in the NFL, Rodgers, Brees, Brady, Manning, AP, that you would trade RG3 straight up for?

Nope.

[WesB]

No way. Griffin is a one of kind player that can turn a franchise around.

[skinsmarydu]

No way. Griffin is a one of kind player that can turn a franchise around.

And we're (here on ES) even content with the losses, because we know greatness is just around the corner, or hell, it could come this season! When I'm hearing,"Your boy got it done", or "Shoulda had that one", it's better than "Skins? Be serious!"
I know we did the right thing. We got a methodical QB. Now, let's keep him on his feet. No more hard hits, o-line.

[GA Redskins Fan]

Andrew Luck is going to be a premier quarterback for many years. I guarantee you his TD/interception rate will improve in coming years. His college TD/INT numbers were 13/4, 32/8, and 37/10. He's the complete package. If a personnel guy, looking long term, is concerned about Griffin's durability issues given his size and the offense he's asked to run, then a Griffin for Luck trade would make sense.

Ok. Robert Griffin is going to be a premier quarterback for many years. RGIII's TD/interception rate was 15/3, 4/0, 22/8, and 37/6. Luck is not the complete package because he can't match Griffin's speed and athleticism. RGIII IS the complete package. RGIII's size is misleading to those who do not pay attention, but more than sufficient. A trade makes no sense to me and if it does to you, then we will just have to agree to disagree.