The Hobbit BOOK THREAD

[Elessar78]

A place to discuss the book and its relationship to the movie without dropping spoilers for the non-readers.

I was really surprised how much filler was used. The scene in the mountain pass isn't really that far into the book. But it was close to the end of the first movie. I still enjoyed it though, it didn't feel like a Victorian novel that was just getting spread out because they got paid by the word.

[JMS]

Was there a Necromancer in the book? I don't remember him..

Also was there a One armed Goblin King "hunting" the party?

[The Evil Genius]

Was there a Necromancer in the book? I don't remember him..

Also was there a One armed Goblin King "hunting" the party?

The Necromancer was mentioned a few times but never appeared. As for the one armed goblin king, I don't remember him being one armed (are we talking about the one in the caves?) before Bilbo meets Gollum?

[JMS]

The Necromancer was mentioned a few times but never appeared. As for the one armed goblin king, I don't remember him being one armed (are we talking about the one in the caves?) before Bilbo meets Gollum?

Movie Spoiler Alert: In the movie they have a Goblin King who rules in Moriea, who has sworn to wipe out the line of the kings under the lonely mountain. He killed Thorin's grandfather, and father, and Thorin oaken-shield cut his arm off in the battle for Morea..
That's all given as background in the movie... Didn't remember any of that.

Looking at IDB They have Benedict Cumberbatch as playing both Smog and the Necromancer..

[LeesburgSkinFan]

The creature with one arm is an Orc and not a Goblin right?

[JMS]

The creature with one arm is an Orc and not a Goblin right?

I think he was refereed too as the albino giant goblin king.

[Vilandil Tasardur]

Slight confusion here for you guys.

The goblin king is the fat ruler with the bublous sack of a double chin. He IS in the novel.

The one armed pale orc is an orc, not a goblin. He is NOT in the novel; though his backstory is in the literature. His (I believe grandson) is mentioned briefly in the novel but his presence in the story appears to have been added because otherwise the only main antagonist wouldn't even appear for 4+ hours of film.

[Forehead]

Well a few things. Goblins and Orcs were the same thing in Tolkien's writing...I believe he used goblin early and switched to orc in later literature.

When determining whether to go through the forest, Gandalf says (this is in the book) something about not being able to go through the lands of the Necromancer to the South. I always assumed he was referring to Sauron.

As for the Goblin King...it's been awhile since I read the book, but I'm fairly certain he was never mentioned as having one arm in the book.

[stevemcqueen1]

Well a few things. Goblins and Orcs were the same thing in Tolkien's writing...I believe he used goblin early and switched to orc in later literature.

When determining whether to go through the forest, Gandalf says (this is in the book) something about not being able to go through the lands of the Necromancer to the South. I always assumed he was referring to Sauron.

As for the Goblin King...it's been awhile since I read the book, but I'm fairly certain he was never mentioned as having one arm in the book.

I believe everything you stated is correct.

I'm rereading the hobbit and I noticed he uses goblins interchangeably with orcs. I don't remember him using the word orc at all in the book actually but I could be wrong. Point being goblins = orcs, although there are lots of different clans and breeds of orcs.

You're also right about the Necromancer being his name for Sauron in The Hobbit.

And yes, there was no mention of Goblin King being one armed in the book. Another poster seemed to have it right, the Goblin king was a great big fat headed Goblin who gets his head cut off by Gandalf or Thorin in the scene where Gandalf rescues Bilbo and the dwarves from the Goblins when they're captured in the mountain caves.

---------- Post added January-14th-2013 at 05:02 PM ----------

I'm questioning consistency. Trolls in the LOTR didn't say anything. Trolls, so far in the movie, talk a lot. What gives?

The trolls in the hobbit talked. And presumably wore clothes because Bilbo attempts to pick their pockets. In the book he gives them this somewhat anachronistic, slangy and ignorant sounding English bully boy style of speaking that would have been comic to children reading the book in his day. It's kind of the same style of dialogue Peter Jackson gave the Orcs in Two Towers, particularly the scenes where they are taking the Hobbits to Isengard.

As someone else pointed out, the hobbit was a children's book and predates the rest of his work so it occasionally breaks canon and oversimplifies things. I still love it. I think it's actually his most charming and entertaining work.

[AsburySkinsFan]

I believe everything you stated is correct.

I'm rereading the hobbit and I noticed he uses goblins interchangeably with orcs. I don't remember him using the word orc at all in the book actually but I could be wrong. Point being goblins = orcs, although there are lots of different clans and breeds of orcs.

look at the post directly above yours.

[China]

You guys keep differentiating between goblins and orcs. I'm not so sure there really is much of a difference:

In The Book of Lost Tales the names Orcs and goblin are given to creatures who enslave and war with the Elves. Christopher Tolkien notes that whilst in the Tale of Tinúviel the author clearly differentiates between "goblins and Orcs", the two terms appear to be synonymous in the Tale of Turambar.

The Qenya Lexicon from approximately 1915 defines Orc as meaning "monster, demon", and the Gnomish Lexicon dated 1917 defines Orc as "goblin", alongside a definition of Gong as "one of a tribe of the Orcs, a goblin".

The term Orc does occur twice; once in an instance where Gandalf is trying to scare Bilbo by mentioning creatures of the wilderness "goblins, hobgoblins, and orcs of the worst description," and again when the narrator mentions Orcs as nothing but large goblins, as well as in the Elvish name of Thorin's sword, Orcrist.

In The Lord of the Rings, Orc is used predominantly, and goblin appears mostly in the Hobbits' speech. The second volume of the novel, The Two Towers, contains passages where the more generic 'goblin' is used to describe Saruman's Uruk-hai as being different from the usual 'Orc':

There were four goblin-soldiers of greater stature, swart, slant-eyed, with thick legs and large hands. They were armed with short broad-bladed swords, not with the curved scimitars usual with Orcs: and they had bows of yew, in length and shape like the bows of Men.[11]

And:

Upon a stake in the middle was set a great goblin head; upon its shattered helm the white badge could still be seen.[12]

The "white badge" mentioned in the latter passage makes it clear that the beheaded goblin was one of the Uruk-hai. Tolkien writes that these bore a white Elf-rune with the value of "S" on their helmets.

Tolkien also wrote the following note, appearing in some editions of The Hobbit:

Orc is not an English word. It occurs in one or two places but is usually translated goblin (or hobgoblin for the larger kinds).

The original edition of The Hobbit and early drafts of The Lord of the Rings first used goblin everywhere and used hobgoblin for larger, more evil goblins.

[AsburySkinsFan]

A place to discuss the book and its relationship to the movie without dropping spoilers for the non-readers.

Ugh!! Again? I hate it when they make a book out of the movie, they always stink!

[Elessar78]

I disagree. I think a few have been done pretty well. People just have to let go of the idea that it'll be completely faithful to the book. I treat it as it's own story not as an adaptation of the book.

[dfitzo53]

I disagree. I think a few have been done pretty well. People just have to let go of the idea that it'll be completely faithful to the book. I treat it as it's own story not as an adaptation of the book.

I'm wondering if you read his post carefully.

I for one found it pleasantly humorous.

[Forehead]

Checked and confirmed, the "Necromancer" referred to in The Hobbit is Sauron. He wasn't in Mordor at the time, he was further north.