Vote RG3 for NFL rookie of the year

[PigskinPhat]

http://http://www.nfl.com/m/voting/rookies/2012/YEAR/0

[STBonecrusher21]

I will not stop voting.

[RiverboatGambler]

I love how they leave out turnovers, rushing yards rush TDs and all the other stats. This is setup for Luck to win. What a joke.

[Kindred]

I love how they leave out turnovers, rushing yards rush TDs and all the other stats. This is setup for Luck to win. What a joke.

ya right? how could they leave out interceptions and fumbles for the RBs. seriously. Its even more clever with M46 in there to potentially lure votes away from RG3 from skin fans.

[Bubble Screen]

I love how they leave out turnovers, rushing yards rush TDs and all the other stats. This is setup for Luck to win. What a joke.

Come on now. That would be like listing the number of strikeouts or errors in the Trout-Cabrera race for MVP.

I actually think Wilson should probably win it now, to be honest. Both he and Luck each won 11 games. But Wilson broke Peyton Manning's rookie record for most passing TDs. Plus Wilson was the hottest of the 3, down the stretch. Even though Luck's turnovers aren't listed (and rightfully so), I think they will be factored in. Or should be. And I also think the fact that RG3 missed time, should also be factored. Plus he didn't have all that many passing yards. As of this minute, taking off the burgundy colored glasses, I'd have to give it to Wilson. Of course, if RG3 goes out and lights it up this Sunday, then all bets are off.

[brandymac27]

OMG, I'm so conflicted! I want to vote for Griffin AND Morris!

[FSUSkins24]

Haha don't worry about putting ALL of the stats Pepsi....

[STBonecrusher21]

Come on now. That would be like listing the number of strikeouts or errors in the Trout-Cabrera race for MVP..

Are you kidding me?!

Strikeouts effect 1 AB. And errors would be a defensive stat, and if you mean on his hits that is effected by his average.

Turnovers effect the entire outcome of a football game. As do the QB rush yards and rush TDs.

[Bubble Screen]

Are you kidding me?!

Strikeouts effect 1 AB. And errors would be a defensive stat, and if you mean on his hits that is effected by his average.

Turnovers effect the entire outcome of a football game. As do the QB rush yards and rush TDs.

My point was, you don't list negative stats in a contest like this. That's not to say they shouldn't be factored in though.

[Toe Jam]

Luck shouldn't even be considered IMO. Dude's a turnover machine.

[RiverboatGambler]

@BubbleScreen Yea it should. Rush TDs matter and Griff Rushed for 7 of them an 800 yards for 4000+Total yards with only 7 turnovers. If efficiency stats don't matter then this is a new development when it comes to judging QBs. Wilson has not been consistently good all year and Griff is still playing clean football on a bum knee. Griff deserves it for being consistently productive and consistently clean all season long.

[Kindred]

FYI, for what it's worth, RG3 won 'NFL Fantasy Live': Rookie of the year

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-fantas...ie-of-the-year

[BigMike21]

Come on now. That would be like listing the number of strikeouts or errors in the Trout-Cabrera race for MVP.

I actually think Wilson should probably win it now, to be honest. Both he and Luck each won 11 games. But Wilson broke Peyton Manning's rookie record for most passing TDs. Plus Wilson was the hottest of the 3, down the stretch. Even though Luck's turnovers aren't listed (and rightfully so), I think they will be factored in. Or should be. And I also think the fact that RG3 missed time, should also be factored. Plus he didn't have all that many passing yards. As of this minute, taking off the burgundy colored glasses, I'd have to give it to Wilson. Of course, if RG3 goes out and lights it up this Sunday, then all bets are off.

I'm with you actually. Gotta take the B&G glasses off for this one. I find the award to be such a toss up between the two that RGIII's only playing 91% of the snaps makes the choice for me. My vote for ROY would be for Russell Wilson. On the other hand, this is just some Pepsi fan vote thing so I just voted like 30 times for RGIII

[Bubble Screen]

Luck shouldn't even be considered IMO. Dude's a turnover machine.

So was Peyton Manning in his rookie season. So was Cam Newton last year.


The Colts only won 2 games last year. They won ELEVEN this year. He's definitely in the running. Don't think he's gonna get it though.

[Murphs56]

Is this award for Offensive Rookie of the year? If it is, Not only should throwing stats be involved, But RUSHING stats as well. RG III ran for like 800 yards.. That's not a factor? For the love of god man