I think RG's a very unique player. I've never seen anyone move like him. He seems to have an unconventional running style and an unconventional feel for the game. If you watch Russell Wilson, he just seems to have a sense of what's happening around him and has a good feel for getting down in a protective position prior to contact. I'm not sure if RG lacks this natural sense or if he's just always pushing the envelope, or something otherwise. I agree with you, in that I also can't put my finger on it.
As I gain perspective on the season, I'm a big Shanahan fan, but I think it's a damn shame RG3's already dealing with such major knee injuries.
I also believe his unique footwork and that unique sense of balance and light-on-his-feet ability is the key to his throwing power and accuracy, and I hope that won't be impacted long-term by the knee injuries.
Having said all that I'm still optimistic that RG will solve all these problems, bc of who he is, and how smart he is. But there's part of me that fears he just won't be durable enough to play the game in the ways that take advantage of all his unique abilities.
I also feel his unique abilities deserve a dominant OL, just to give them their best chance to make the impact I suspect they can. With all our needs throughout the team, I'd still focus continuing to build right there.
I think he likes to outrun guys. He's got better straight line speed then most players in the NFL do. I have a feeling he feels that he can outrun anyone and he LIKES to out run everyone. Not a good mix.
Also, Morris runs a dive on the zone read and and Robert would take it outside. Kaepernick and Wilson have both the dive and the jet sweep (running backs going off tackle as opposed to between guards) and then they pull out and run power up the middle. It's not a huge deal, but if you do that enough, you give the defense more confusing looks.
I think we'll be able to do more of this type of thing with Helu coming back (if healthy).
FREE ROB
I think it's because he flourished under Shanahan in his rookie year. I mean, think how he would be used: in the slot to replace an aging veteran and as a return man. Now, Moss played incredibly this season so the thought of going after Royal seems ridiculous in hindsight, but hey, look at the other Hokie receiver on our roster. Joshua Morgan is looking great. I wonder what his feelings are on the Niners going to the Super Bowl after him getting here.
I think that's his mindset too, he likes the idea that he's faster than everyone on the field, and likes to flaunt it. It's a bit of an ego thing, but unlike a lot of players he backs it up. Unfortunately, that leaves him open to injuries more often than most QBs, and is something he'll have to tone down in subsequent years. He knows that on any given play he could be in the endzone, from anywhere on the field, and that pushes him to take risks. He's going to have to learn to live with just getting 10 yard chunks at a time, like Rodgers or Roethlisberger.
He was the 49ers leading receiver before he got hurt. Low cost, high upside. Not flashy, but a potentially good investment. And other teams had interest in him, including the Niners, who wanted to re-sign him. Better than dropping money for some other guys.
I also wouldn't call him a bust, unless you think he was bought in to be the number one guy, which he wasn't. In a run heavy offense he played catching 48 balls for 510 yards isn't shabby. Plus he got boned out of two touchdowns with a stupid "tripping" penalty versus the Giants and another one versus the Ravens where he clearly crossed the plain and was called out and we didn't challenge it for whatever reason.
Eh, I don't think I would call him a bust, underperforming maybe, but not quite a bust.
He was 82nd in the league in receptions while being 84th in targets, and was 92nd in yards, and 94th in YPC. So he wasn't targeted all that much to begin with, but he slightly underperformed even after taking that into account.
I think it's best to reserve judgement on him until after this year, ideally with Garcon and Davis both healthy, so we can see what his role really will be in our offense when it's running on all cylinders and what his abilities ultimately are in that situation.
I've got a "loose" MCL from the motorcycle accident that forced me out of the Navy. Every once in a blue moon it'll buckle with me just standing still, and suddenly I'm on the floor. (Like Peyton said in that commercial, "Walk it off, rub some dirt on it!" LOL)
Granted, I'm a whole lot older than Robert, and I've waited tables and bartended for 27 years on this knee since the injury, (somebody's got to feed the world,haha), but I know I'm nowhere near as important as he is, and I want him back 100% for years to come.
There are currently 8 users browsing this thread. (3 members and 5 guests)