MTV: J.J. Abrams' 'Star Wars 7': What Will It Look Like

[Titaw]

That would be pretty good. On the surface, I like that you have Palpatine resurrected as a ghost, because, he'd probably know that trick, but there's nothing in the 6 star wars movies that indicate that SIth can come back as ghosts. We've only seen Jedi come back. And, when Anakin comes back as a ghost, its as his younger self before he turned to the dark side (according to the Special Editions). That kind of implies that only Jedi come back.

Still, i wonder if Christen Hayden's Anakin, Obiwan, and Yoda ghosts will be in the movies. In the star wars novels, jedi ghosts can only stick around for a few years before they have to "move on" but thats not cannon.

If Luke and Leia are prominent in the movies, id really be interested in seeing both of them as Jedi Masters on a revived Jedi counsel (maybe with some other stragglers who'd been hiding since the Purge). From a logical perspective, it would make sense for Leia to be a Jedi as opposed to a politician - There are plenty of politicians who could help rebuild the republic, but not many force-users to rebuild the Jedi. I'd be even more interested in seeing one of Leia's kids turn to the dark side and Luke have to kill him/her (kind of like obiwan being willing to kill anakin).

The thing is Palpatine talked about Darth Plaguis knowing how to do it and if the Jedi know how to do it, the Sith should know how to do it as well, especially the Sith Lord. It wouldn't be a stretch and as long as they didn't try to explain it like midichlorians than we should be fine. I really think that "ghost" Palpatine should be the only real tie-in from the OT. Luke and Leia could sit in on the Jedi council and have LIMITED roles but new Jedi that were taught by Luke and Leia should be the Masters that are featured.

[talk show host]

That's a cool story arc but it seems very similar to what we've already seen in the prequel trilogy. It would be interesting if they got away from the narrowly focused episodes that we've grown accustomed to. I wouldn't mind zooming out and following something else. There is more in the Star Wars universe than a handful of Jedi and their friends.

Episodes I - IX are about the skywalker family. After Ep IX is released, Disney's going to open up the universe and we'll probably have 1-2 movies per year (like they do with marvel) set in the universe that follow other stories (bounty hunters, knights of the old republic, coruscant politics, etc.) This isnt specualtion, but Disney's already said theyre going to do this. You just might hvae to wait 10 years before you start seeing these movies (unless they decide to get them in development concurrent with the final trilogy).

[TD_washingtonredskins]

Episodes I - IX are about the skywalker family. After Ep IX is released, Disney's going to open up the universe and we'll probably have 1-2 movies per year (like they do with marvel) set in the universe that follow other stories (bounty hunters, knights of the old republic, coruscant politics, etc.) This isnt specualtion, but Disney's already said theyre going to do this. You just might hvae to wait 10 years before you start seeing these movies (unless they decide to get them in development concurrent with the final trilogy).

Oh OK, makes sense.

[talk show host]

The thing is Palpatine talked about Darth Plaguis knowing how to do it and if the Jedi know how to do it, the Sith should know how to do it as well, especially the Sith Lord. It wouldn't be a stretch and as long as they didn't try to explain it like midichlorians than we should be fine. I really think that "ghost" Palpatine should be the only real tie-in from the OT. Luke and Leia could sit in on the Jedi council and have LIMITED roles but new Jedi that were taught by Luke and Leia should be the Masters that are featured.

Palpatines story about Plaguis ability was the same thing as the jedi-ghost trick. Plaguis learned how to prevent himself (and presumably others) from DYING - not from living on as a ghost after he died. Remember, Palpatine referred to the ability as being "unnatural" and something you could only learn if you embrased the dark side. If what Palpatine was referring to was in fact the ghost-trick, then that would mean that Qui-gon, Yoda, and Obi-wan used a dark-side power to become ghosts, and i dont think thats likely.

I also dont know if I would even want to see a Palpatine ghost story line. His rise to power, rule, and ultimate destruction was chronicled in Episodes I-VI. Other than being a "mentor" to new sith, i dont even know what purpose he would serve in the story or what threat he could pose.

[Titaw]

Palpatines story about Plaguis ability was the same thing as the jedi-ghost trick. Plaguis learned how to prevent himself (and presumably others) from DYING - not from living on as a ghost after he died. Remember, Palpatine referred to the ability as being "unnatural" and something you could only learn if you embrased the dark side. If what Palpatine was referring to was in fact the ghost-trick, then that would mean that Qui-gon, Yoda, and Obi-wan used a dark-side power to become ghosts, and i dont think thats likely.

I also dont know if I would even want to see a Palpatine ghost story line. His rise to power, rule, and ultimate destruction was chronicled in Episodes I-VI. Other than being a "mentor" to new sith, i dont even know what purpose he would serve in the story or what threat he could pose.

There are abilities that both sides share, this could be one. Palpatine was simply thrown down the reactor shaft, he could have used the old Obi-Wan disappear before I am struck down trick. I get the conflict here but there needs to be continuity on both sides of the force. Even if they are in a limited capacity, we need to see the proverbial passing of the torch.

[Mr. Sinister]

Also, not sure if it's been mentioned, or if it is already a forgone conclusion in the mind of most Star Wars fans, but:

John Williams' score is a must have. Gots to have it.

[BRAVEONTHEWARPATH93]

I'm still lukewarm on this. I'll probably be like this until I see the first preview, which probably about 2-3 years off.

Abrams said he isn't committed to the 2015 date

[talk show host]

There are abilities that both sides share, this could be one. Palpatine was simply thrown down the reactor shaft, he could have used the old Obi-Wan disappear before I am struck down trick. I get the conflict here but there needs to be continuity on both sides of the force. Even if they are in a limited capacity, we need to see the proverbial passing of the torch.

Not necessarily. The Phantom Menace told us there was a prophecy about one who would bring balance to the force. Presumably, Anakin brought balance to the force when he killed Palpatine and died himself. At that point, there were no more sith. Master and Apprentice were both destroyed. If Palpatine wasnt destroyed by Anakin, and Palpatine survived as a ghost to train more sith, then the prophecy Lucas introduced in Ep1 doesnt make sense.

---------- Post added January-31st-2013 at 10:44 AM ----------

Also, not sure if it's been mentioned, or if it is already a forgone conclusion in the mind of most Star Wars fans, but:

John Williams' score is a must have. Gots to have it.

We still need the classic theme incorporated, sure, but John Williams is 80 years old (will be 82-23 by the time the movie would be ready for him to do any work) and his most recent movie soundtracks have been pretty uninspired. Ive got no problem if Abrams uses another composer.

[LLandryistheshiz]

Not necessarily. The Phantom Menace told us there was a prophecy about one who would bring balance to the force. Presumably, Anakin brought balance to the force when he killed Palpatine and died himself. At that point, there were no more sith. Master and Apprentice were both destroyed. If Palpatine wasnt destroyed by Anakin, and Palpatine survived as a ghost to train more sith, then the prophecy Lucas introduced in Ep1 doesnt make sense.

---------- Post added January-31st-2013 at 10:44 AM ----------

Does bringing balance to the force mean that there is only good left? Or that there is equal balance of light and dark?

[Botched]

My god, this thread is absolutely bursting with nerd.

I swear I haven't opened it 157 times.

[Major Harris]

No no no....Anakin brought balance to the force, it just wasn't the way the. Jedi interpreted it....at the onset of ep. 4, how many Jedi were left and how many sith were left? 2 each. That is the way I always saw it.

[USS Redskins]

I never understood the "prophecy" about balance to the force....

I mean the Jedi want Balance? They destroyed the siths thousands of years before and the nice side of the force was dominant. Why would they want/need balance with the chosen one?

After Episode 2 I can see the need for balance but not in Ep1 when it was clear they were ignorant of the dark side for decades.

Stupid crap.

Anyway - I am looking forward to a Good Star Wars Movie (Jar JAr Bink-less and any references to Ep 1-3). And I do hope Abrams uses the original cast to some degree. It wouldnt be any good without them imo.

[Titaw]

Not necessarily. The Phantom Menace told us there was a prophecy about one who would bring balance to the force. Presumably, Anakin brought balance to the force when he killed Palpatine and died himself. At that point, there were no more sith. Master and Apprentice were both destroyed. If Palpatine wasnt destroyed by Anakin, and Palpatine survived as a ghost to train more sith, then the prophecy Lucas introduced in Ep1 doesnt make sense.[COLOR="Gold"]

Maybe, the prophecy hasn't been fulfilled and Anakin wasn't the one to bring balance. Besides, each side needs each other to be balanced.

[talk show host]

Maybe, the prophecy hasn't been fulfilled and Anakin wasn't the one to bring balance. Besides, each side needs each other to be balanced.

I think the whole prophecy is stupid, just like jar-jar and midichlorians, but Lucas introduced the idea anyway.

Both sides do not need eachother to be balanced. The force is in all living things and binds things together. The jedi use the force for good. The Sith use the force to cause death. Therefore, by their very existence, the sith create an imbalance in the force. For the force to be balanced again, the sith must be destroyed. Thats the only way ive ever interpreted the prophecy.

[Coolio47]

Interesting fact: R2D2 has a cameo in the Star Trek(2009).